Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
Science

First Thorium Nuclear Clocks Begin to Tick 75

Researchers in Vienna and Beijing have independently built the first nuclear clocks based on oscillations inside thorium nuclei, marking a major milestone for a field that could eventually produce highly portable, ultra-precise timekeepers. The clocks are already precise enough to lose only about a second over millions of years. The New York Times reports: The first nuclear clocks are not going to immediately supplant the worldwide network of atomic clocks, whose steady ticking we rely on for GPS and the definition of a second. Nor have they captured the record for most precise timepiece; the best atomic clocks are about 10,000 times more reliable and would take more than 100 billion years to lose one second.

But nuclear clocks hold a bevy of potential advantages over existing atomic clocks. One day, they could be more reliable than the leading atomic versions, and nuclear clocks could be made more portable. They even hold the ability to search for certain kinds of dark matter -- the invisible stuff whose clumps make up 83 percent of the matter in the universe. If a particle of dark matter passed through the thorium nuclei, it could register as a wobble in the nuclear clock's otherwise steady ticktock.
The findings have been published in the journal Nature.
This discussion has been archived. No new comments can be posted.

First Thorium Nuclear Clocks Begin to Tick

Comments Filter:
    • With the way this world is going, your wish may come true with the ones left are going to be wearing Pip-Boy 3000's and paying with bottlecaps.
    • Confucius say, "Man who wear nuclear wrist watch, strap on tiny tiny clock."
      • Confucius say, "Man who wear nuclear wrist watch, strap on tiny tiny clock."

        Actually, the quote is, "A man with one nuclear watch knows the time; a man with two, also knows the time." :-)

        (Poking fun at Segal's law [wikipedia.org]...)

    • by dsgrntlxmply ( 610492 ) on Friday October 09, 2026 @12:50AM (#66368654)
      When I was quite young, I was given a hand-me-down watch with a glow in the dark dial. A local school had a science fair with a demonstration Geiger counter. The watch dial was nuclear: ZnS/Ra .
    • by fahrbot-bot ( 874524 ) on Friday October 09, 2026 @02:59AM (#66368700)

      That's it.

      Ironically, Iran was making those, in some sort of mountain factory, but ... :-)

    • That's it.

      Bah. I want a nuclear hand grenade. It'd be a hell of a way to shutup that stupid neighbor who keeps complaining to my landlord about my drinking.

    • They exist. (Score:4, Interesting)

      by Gravis Zero ( 934156 ) on Friday October 09, 2026 @04:02PM (#66369460)

      Chip-scale atomic clocks are a thing [microchip.com]. The problem is that they aren't exactly low enough power to be wrist mounted as they need 115 mW constantly. You absolute can make it into a wristwatch (and people have) but it will need regular charging... unless you are using betavoltaic nuclear batteries. [wikipedia.org] However to reach the power output needed with what is on the market, you would need about 120K of them.

      The natural reaction to this is "what's the purpose of building up that kind of arm strength if the batteries are just going to die in 50 years?" and the answer is the diamond battery! [wikipedia.org] This is a newer betavoltaic battery which is in the same power output range but lasts for thousands of years because it's based on Carbon-14.

      Start doing those reps today because the watch of your dreams is 2400Kg.

      • Those diamond batteries were bullshit. The problem is that as the carbon-14 decays, the structure stops being diamond, because it's no longer made of all carbon. After even a decade or two, the diamond structure will be practically gone and the remaining carbon will impure as balls and in mostly graphite form. Once the structure is damaged enough, it will no longer hold itself together. I suppose you could encase the diamond in something like resin but part of the point of using diamond was the electrical p

        • Those diamond batteries were bullshit.

          Sir, I am an expert in chemistry having had multiple minutes of experience in searching for information about it. As such, I defer to you because sure, like I would know. :)

          It's not that I don't like chemistry, it's just that I think the reality needs to refactor it's lower level APIs, starting with mathematics. I'm not saying it's wasteful but too much computational power goes into Pi. They should make it a simple integer value like 3 and make e like... 2. ;)

          • Personally, on this matter, I defer to Phil Mason, Ph.D., who is a chemist specializing in nuclear chemistry. He put a video up on his thunderf00t channel when this thing came out in the news explaining why it's bullshit.

    • There used to be nuclear wrist watches , but the.nuclear bit showed time; it didn't measure time.

      (Radium dials)

    • Will a Geiger counter tick steadily next to a nuclear clock?
    • Carpal Tunnel Cancer.
  • by 93 Escort Wagon ( 326346 ) on Thursday October 08, 2026 @11:02PM (#66368618)

    They even hold the ability to search for certain kinds of dark matter -- the invisible stuff whose clumps make up 83 percent of the matter in the universe.

    It's pretty impressive that we know so much about the stuff and can make those sorts of declarations.

    • yes, decades of research, development of more and better methods and instruments, cross-referencing discoveries from elementary particles to the largest structures in the visible universe do produce far reaching insights.

      sadly, the work that goes into them is often underappreciated because it isn't easy to understand.

    • They even hold the ability to search for certain kinds of dark matter -- the invisible stuff whose clumps make up 83 percent of the matter in the universe.

      It's pretty impressive that we know so much about the stuff and can make those sorts of declarations.

      Its pretty impressive that we can manage to get millions in taxpayer funding over decades of study, call the field “dark” to make it sound really cool, but in reality still don’t have a single fucking clue as to what all that cool-sounding “dark” shit is.

      Which we also estimate there is a LOT of, making this whole idea that a clock might run into 80% of the universe seem silly. It should be smashing into dark matter almost constantly unless we also discover it magically evades

      • by gtall ( 79522 )

        Science is hard, get over it. The Universe doesn't send its secrets dancing naked in front us shouting "see me!!". Actually, we do not know what quantum particles of anything actually are. We make observations and use those to winnow out mathematical theories of them, but in essence we do not know them as a "ding an sich".

        • Science is hard, get over it. The Universe doesn't send its secrets dancing naked in front us shouting "see me!!". Actually, we do not know what quantum particles of anything actually are. We make observations and use those to winnow out mathematical theories of them, but in essence we do not know them as a "ding an sich".

          Science is hard. Believing science isn’t ripping taxpayers off to fund water-is-wet studies and fluff “expert” arrogance, is even harder.

          Do you require a theoretical proof to understand why, or is Greed N. Corruption, CEO of US Capitalism dancing naked in front of taxpayers enough?

      • Re: (Score:3, Interesting)

        Its pretty impressive that we can manage to get millions in taxpayer funding over decades of study

        It is pretty impressive you're concerned about pocket money.

        The NSF total budget since the year 2000 is about $200B.

        The tax breaks to the people with net worth above $1B for the same period is about $3T.

        • Its pretty impressive that we can manage to get millions in taxpayer funding over decades of study

          It is pretty impressive you're concerned about pocket money.

          The NSF total budget since the year 2000 is about $200B.

          The tax breaks to the people with net worth above $1B for the same period is about $3T.

          Do you want me to ask how many tax breaks come in the form of billionaire donations to science foundations, or would that be too inconvenient?

          • Re:83%, you say? (Score:5, Informative)

            by Mr. Dollar Ton ( 5495648 ) on Friday October 09, 2026 @11:03AM (#66369160)

            Do you want me to ask how many tax breaks come in the form of billionaire donations to science foundations, or would that be too inconvenient?

            Sure, you can ask, and I'll tell you right away. It is here:

            https://indicators.sciphil.org... [sciphil.org]

            $27 billion a year last year, a lot less than a quarter of the tax breaks, and that's mostly spent on vanity projects of the "make me live forever" kind, and most of that isn't donated on the research actual merits, but on the whims and misconceptions of the donor. Therefore the impact to actual science isn't even remotely comparable.

      • Re:83%, you say? (Score:5, Informative)

        by ArchieBunker ( 132337 ) on Friday October 09, 2026 @07:14AM (#66368872)

        Its pretty impressive that we can manage to get millions in taxpayer funding over decades of study,

        You really want to go down that road? Let's begin with the Gulf War 3.0.

      • Its pretty impressive that we can manage to get millions in taxpayer funding over decades of study

        It's not impressive, it's essential. Taxpayer funding for things people have considered irrelevant have incidentally lead to a whole world of real world benefits for average people.

        Take for example the International Space Station. Many people think this is a waste of money. Those same people now benefit from:
        - HEPA filtration in vacuum cleaners and cars (originally developed for long term space survival)
        - Better medical diagnostics (space based sensors for science no one though relevant led to modulated x-r

        • The return on investment from tech created for space vs that based on direct funding of science and tech is pathetic. Theres almost nothing the space program gave rise to that wouldnt have happened anyway. And HEPA filters? Really? That barrel you're scraping probably has a hole in the bottom by now.

          • 'That barrel you're scraping probably has a hole in the bottom by now.'

            I'll try to remember that one and use it elsewhere

          • Theres almost nothing the space program gave rise to that wouldnt have happened anyway.

            A phrase used by every science denier in history.

            Have some education: The world of science is split into direct research and incidental discoveries. A lot of your life is attributed to the latter. There's no causal reason why it "wouldn't have happened anyway". Many of these discoveries took years for their actual applications to become apparent and as no one was seeking these discoveries there's no reason for any sane person to believe they would have been discovered.

            As for return on investment, that's not

            • by Viol8 ( 599362 )

              Wow, a whole field of straw men, its a wonder you can find your way out.

              If you think any of the discoveries made by the US space program wouldn't have eventually happened anyway - sure, it may have taken a bit longer - then you're deluded. Necessity is the mother of invention etc. I'm not arguing there shouldn't be a space program, thats a different matter , but saying it somehow lead to a huge leap in technology that wouldn't have happened otherwise? No, sorry. Where was the space program when the steam en

  • Another useful article that links to a paywall FFS

  • What's accuracy being measured against? And to what scale picoseconds?

    Achilles, where's that tortoise?

    • by HiThere ( 15173 )

      Well, it's not measuring dates, but it's measuring steady intervals. And IIRC correctly, the scale if femtoseconds. (Nope, that was a laser-comb clock. Perhaps attoseconds.)

  • Thanks, BeauHD, for swooping in, scooping my submission [slashdot.org] from two days ago, and posting a worse summary.
  • by necro81 ( 917438 ) on Friday October 09, 2026 @07:16AM (#66368874) Journal
    Atomic clocks work using the energy transitions between different electron orbitals. Nuclear clocks [wikipedia.org] work by using energy transitions within the nucleus itself - the difference between the lowest energy arrangement of the protons+neutrons and excited states (isomers).

    Normally you need a serious punch to get a nucleus into an excited state: x-rays, gamma rays, or bombardment with energic particles. It so happens that thorium-229 requires the lowest energy to get to an excited state, and that can be achieved with deep-UV (148 nm) light. Laser light at that wavelength has only recently become possible. Also: Th-229 does not really exist in nature, you have to extract it from the decay of U-235, which itself has low natural abundance.

    So it's pretty cool stuff, and this first demonstration hints at what could be possible in the future. Atomic clocks use light in the microwave range; this nuclear clock uses light in a frequency band five orders or magnitude higher, and so could theoretically have that much greater precision. And because the fundamental phenomenon occurs in the nucleus rather than the electron cloud, it's much less susceptible to external interference.
    • by AmiMoJo ( 196126 )

      I was interesting by the article's comment that it could lead to smaller clocks, but that doesn't seem likely from what you are saying. At the moment a "chip scale" atomic clock is a metal can maybe the size of a consumer CPU, and pulling quite a bit of power.

    • by Khyber ( 864651 )

      "Laser light at that wavelength has only recently become possible."

      Lolwut? We've been able to run multiple frequency-doubling passes on various laser sources to reach most any range of UV laser for well over a decade. The problem is you get not a whole lot of radiant output - less than half a watt output at gobs of watts input.

      Also, 148nm is not deep UV, that is flat-out Vacuum UV.

    • ..And because the fundamental phenomenon occurs in the nucleus rather than the electron cloud, it's much less susceptible to external interference.

      A..nuclear tourbillion?

      A..nuc'billion?

      Cool.

  • by reg ( 5428 )
    Wish we had changed Unix seconds to TAI instead of UTC when dropping 32-bit... Who cares where the stars are.
  • Honest question for the real time nerds out there.

    Isn't the length of a day variable?

    Like I understand the want and desire to more accurately time a day, and the scientific reasons to. But we're trying to precisely map the time of a spin of a globe as it spins in orbit around a sun - and to my understanding that day length varies based on anything from the amount of groundwater we pump out of the ground to the varying cyclical distance of our moon to our surface. And from what I understand we have to co
    • Defining time by the earths rotation? That ship sailed back in the 60s.

      • But we still do define time by the earth's rotation. Thus the leap second to keep the earth noon from drifting relative to atomic timekeeping.
        • by Viol8 ( 599362 )

          You got it back to front - if we still defined the second by the earths rotation by definition we wouldn't need any leap seconds.

    • Correct. So it will be out of sync and so will Bezo's 10,000 year clock in the mountain.

      speeding up
      https://news.slashdot.org/stor... [slashdot.org]

      slowing down
      https://news.slashdot.org/stor... [slashdot.org]

  • If a particle of dark matter passed through the thorium nuclei, it could register as a wobble in the nuclear clock's otherwise steady ticktock.

    Or it could not, since we have no idea what this dark matter could be made of, if it even exists.

    • by PPH ( 736903 )

      It's the recprocal of the Street Light Effect. [wikipedia.org] You don't look for where it is likely to be or where it's easiest to see (under the streetlight). You search where the rewards of sucess are likely to be the highest (citation for your research papers, Nobel prize in physics, etc.) Drunks search under the streetlight because the reward will always be the same. Found my car keys. Now I guess I'll (hic) be driving home.

  • by Anonymous Coward
    The current cesium clocks are as small as a sugar cube. How much more portable do we need them to be? And is it really likely they will be smaller than cesium clocks? I am doubtful.
  • In advance, I promise I'm not promoting any conspiracy theories here, this is a sincere question...

    There's an old, largely ridiculed idea of the "nuclear hand-grenade", with most references talking about using a particular isomer of Halfnium. The primary objection I've seen to the idea is we have no practical way to "excite" nucleons in any meaningful sense - at least not without gear the size of a particle accelerator. But... This clock appears to be making use of exactly such an effect, just at sub-fiss
  • How can we expect a femtosecond accurate clock when walking across the room towards it will cause your time to drift relative to its time?

    • This is actually a serious problem with trying to accurately measure "the time" in a global sense. Time is affected by gravity and movement, so a second in one place isn't the same as a second in another place (even if both places are on the surface of Earth). You can't really measure Earth time much more accurately than current atomic clocks, as the variation in the length of a second from place to place starts to outweigh the accuracy of the clocks.

      So the answer is that your nuclear clock is indeed accura

Any given program will expand to fill available memory.

Working...