The Dream of Sending a Submarine Through the Methane Seas of Saturn's Moon Titan (nytimes.com) 51
"Mars, Shmars; this voyager is looking forward to a submarine ride under the icebergs on Saturn's strange moon," says the New York Times, introducing a piece by cosmic affairs correspondent Dennis Overbye:
What could be more exciting than flying a helicopter over the deserts of Mars? How about playing Captain Nemo on Saturn's large, foggy moon Titan — plumbing the depths of a methane ocean, dodging hydrocarbon icebergs and exploring an ancient, frigid shoreline of organic goo a billion miles from the sun? Those are the visions that danced through my head recently...diverted to the farther reaches of the solar system by the news that Kraken Mare, an ocean of methane on Titan, had recently been gauged for depth and probably went at least 1,000 feet down. That is as deep as nuclear submarines will admit to going. The news rekindled my dreams of what I think would be the most romantic of space missions: a voyage on, and ultimately even under, the oceans of Titan...
NASA recently announced that it would launch a drone called Dragonfly to the Saturnian moon in 2026. Proposals have also circulated for an orbiter, a floating probe that could splash down in a lake, even a robotic submarine. "The Titan submarine is still going," said Dr. Valerio Poggiali, research associate at the Cornell Center for Astrophysics and Planetary Science, in an email — although it is unlikely to happen before Titan's next summer, around 2047. By then, he said, there will be more ambient light and the submarine conceivably could communicate on a direct line to Earth with no need of an orbiting radio relay.
Titan is the weirdest place in the solar system, in some regards, and also the world most like our own. Like Earth, it has a thick atmosphere of mostly nitrogen (the only moon that has much of an atmosphere at all), and like Earth, it has weather, rain, rivers and seas. But on this world, when it rains, it rains gasoline. Hydrocarbon material drifts down like snow and is shaped into dunes by nitrogen winds. Rivers have carved canyons through mountains of frozen soot, and layers of ice float on subsurface oceans of ammonia. The prevailing surface temperature is minus 290 degrees Fahrenheit. A chemical sludge that optimistic astronomers call "prebiotic" creeps along under an oppressive brown sky. Besides Earth, Titan is the only world in the universe that is known to harbor liquid on its surface — with everything that could imply.
NASA recently announced that it would launch a drone called Dragonfly to the Saturnian moon in 2026. Proposals have also circulated for an orbiter, a floating probe that could splash down in a lake, even a robotic submarine. "The Titan submarine is still going," said Dr. Valerio Poggiali, research associate at the Cornell Center for Astrophysics and Planetary Science, in an email — although it is unlikely to happen before Titan's next summer, around 2047. By then, he said, there will be more ambient light and the submarine conceivably could communicate on a direct line to Earth with no need of an orbiting radio relay.
Titan is the weirdest place in the solar system, in some regards, and also the world most like our own. Like Earth, it has a thick atmosphere of mostly nitrogen (the only moon that has much of an atmosphere at all), and like Earth, it has weather, rain, rivers and seas. But on this world, when it rains, it rains gasoline. Hydrocarbon material drifts down like snow and is shaped into dunes by nitrogen winds. Rivers have carved canyons through mountains of frozen soot, and layers of ice float on subsurface oceans of ammonia. The prevailing surface temperature is minus 290 degrees Fahrenheit. A chemical sludge that optimistic astronomers call "prebiotic" creeps along under an oppressive brown sky. Besides Earth, Titan is the only world in the universe that is known to harbor liquid on its surface — with everything that could imply.
Here's an idea (Score:2)
If you send a submarine to Titan, please send James Cameron with it. One way. Somebody needs to pay for Titanic and Celine Dion.
To give credit where it's due... (Score:2)
I am somewhat disappointed that they mention the Titan submarine right in the headline, but left out the design group at NASA Glenn [nasa.gov] that designed it [nasa.gov] and put the mission concept together, or give any recognition to (or even mention the names of) any of the people involved.
https://www.nasa.gov/content/t... [nasa.gov]
https://www.sciencedirect.com/... [sciencedirect.com]
https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/pdf/1... [aiaa.org]
https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/1... [aiaa.org]
The animation is also on youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?... [youtube.com] (or in the talk
I wanna see the weather on Titan, before I die. (Score:1)
Ideally as a 4K stream in full color and sound.
So can we please not drag this out forever? Travel time alone is already long enough.
You know, instead of pointless international bickering and time-wasting cancer like Bitcoin and WeWork and octuple-camera iNorexia jewelry.
Re: (Score:2)
It *is* our solar system, so while it sounds kind of boring [youtu.be], we shouldn't wait for a special occasion to see these sorts of natural wonders. There *are* still other options [youtu.be] if it's not otherwise possible in our lifetime.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
You can't breathe in outer space either, so what's the point of going there?
Re: (Score:2)
"can't breathe": wow, I guess nobody thought of that. I guess that's the same reason nobody has invented a way to breathe underwater. Do you suppose we could, say, take some air with us? And maybe wear a pressurized suit and helmet or something in space.
Re: Bad idea... you won't see shit (Score:2)
We already have pictures from the surface of titan: https://www.planetary.org/spac... [planetary.org] . Light there is 1000x less intense than noon sunlight on earth, but plenty enough to take pics.
Re: (Score:2)
For comparison, moonlight on Earth is 400,000 times less intense than sunlight -- but you can still see enough to go for a walk when there's a full moon.
Re: (Score:2)
Saturn (and therefore Titan) is about 10 AU from the Sun, so it receives 10**2 = 100 times less light. I guess the remaining factor of 10 is absorption by its atmosphere, right?
For a literal submarine, there will be additional loss of light due to the absorption by the liquid. Not sure how transparent that stuff is.
Re: (Score:2)
For a literal submarine, there will be additional loss of light due to the absorption by the liquid. Not sure how transparent that stuff is.
The other interesting aspect is how transparent the liquid will be to RF communications, which is a big problem for submarines in salt water on Earth. From the NASA paper [nasa.gov]:
While methane has been shown to be radio frequency (RF) transparent, the presumably more ethane rich composition of Kraken has not yet been shown to be transparent (a topic of ongoing Cassini investigation). As such the submarine, like its terrestrial counterpart will need to surface to communicate.
10 AU, plus optical depth [Re: Bad idea...] (Score:2)
Saturn (and therefore Titan) is about 10 AU from the Sun, so it receives 10**2 = 100 times less light. I guess the remaining factor of 10 is absorption by its atmosphere, right?
Correct. Details here: https://iopscience.iop.org/art... [iop.org]
(see the plot in figure 5).
built it out of ice (Score:2)
liquid methane will be cold enough to freeze water so you could make this thing when you arrive by 3d printing heated water.
then it could be clear and you could see out of it.
Re: (Score:3)
Being in Saturn's shadow? Wikipedia: "Viewed from Earth, Titan reaches an angular distance of about 20 Saturn radii." Assuming that its orbit around Saturn is co-planar with Saturn's around the Sun, and assuming I'm calculating this correctly, that means it's hidden from the Sun by Saturn for about 1/80th of its orbit.
illumination [Re:Bad idea... you won't see shit] (Score:2)
Between the poor lighting due to immense distance from the sun,
You do know that we have landed a probe on Titan (Huygens), and it did take pictures?
The illumination is roughly as bright as a 60-watt bulb one to two meters away.
and being in Saturn's shadow,
Titan occasionally passes through Saturn's shadow, which happens at times around the Saturn equinox (roughly once every 15 Earth years). But >99% of the time Titan is not in Saturns shadow.
Kraken Mare (Score:3)
"Kraken Mare" is an album title-in-waiting, if I ever saw one.
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2)
Prog-tastic!
We haven't even mapped the surface yet (Score:2)
There is so much that is cool about Titan. And we'll get there eventually. But there are quite a few steps we should to take before sending a sub. Like, mapping the surface and finding a lake to send a sub to investigate.
Re: We haven't even mapped the surface yet (Score:3)
Already done. Cassini identified quite a few lakes and even âoeicebergsâ and waves moving.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sc... [dailymail.co.uk]
Cold enough to freeze the balls off a brass monkey (Score:3)
Re: (Score:2)
Cold and far we understand and can deal with. Those are hard problems, not insurmountable.
NASA does the hard problems. It's kind of their thing.
Send a Blimp instead (Score:5, Interesting)
A sub and even a helicopter are the wrong choices for Titan. We should send a blimp. We could have it self inflate from liquid hydrogen. With the methane atmosphere, hydrogen gas isn't flammable. Then we could just float it above the surface and let ambient wind currents carry it around mapping the surface, and touching down on occasion to take a closer look at lakes and sediments.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Sure. So why use any of that energy on flight? Just float around.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
You could deploy sails and navigate by swiveling the sails or rudder. It would be slow but doable.
Re: (Score:2)
Or just let the winds blow the balloon around. It's less intentional but you would probably cover more distance and area because you would use a lot less energy and extend the life of the project.
Re: (Score:2)
Wait what? Is it communicating directly to Earth or to an orbiter? Handheld satellite phones on Earth don't use that much energy.
Re: (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
That does sound like a good idea. Titan's atmosphere is thicker than Earth's and the gravity is lower, so the blimp won't have to be all that big. The main problems I see are navigation (avoiding mountains/hills), energy requirements and complexity/weight to inflate/deflate (unless you do a one time inflation and ditch the tank -- or produce hydrogen on-site maybe on the ground using that methane), things like that. Solar energy on Titan is minimal so even if you made the top of the blimp solar out of solar
Re: (Score:2)
A sub and even a helicopter are the wrong choices for Titan. We should send a blimp. We could have it self inflate from liquid hydrogen. With the methane atmosphere, hydrogen gas isn't flammable. Then we could just float it above the surface and let ambient wind currents carry it around mapping the surface, and touching down on occasion to take a closer look at lakes and sediments.
I love the idea of a Titan airship
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/cita... [nasa.gov]
https://arc.aiaa.org/doi/abs/1... [aiaa.org]
-but the quadcopter is a lot smaller.
Competition (Score:2, Funny)
Re: (Score:1)
The unique environment of Titan (Score:2)
There is no place like Titan, not even Detroit of the 1950s: lakes of alkanes, shorelines of frozen petroleum, air thick with hydrocarbon distillates. NASA needs to characterize this unique non-ecosystem before colonists swarm in and, human nature being what it is, start cleaning up the air so they can supplement it with oxygen and muck everything up with trees and flowers.
Seas of Meth (Score:4, Funny)
A sea of meth is not what this country needs
Some good methane sea science fiction (Score:2)
I can highly recommend some science fiction that has action under methane seas. First off, Ilium by Dan Simmons is a true classic, with fine references to the Homerian classic. A Darkling Sea, by Cambias, is also very good.
Künsken's Quantum Magician also has those settings, but is not very good.
Hydrocarbons (Score:2)
I am somewhat surprised, that no one has proposed yet, that we should bring Freedom and Democracy to Titan ASAP.
Just ignore this. (Score:2)
Dare Mighty Things (Score:1)