Slashdot is powered by your submissions, so send in your scoop

 



Forgot your password?
typodupeerror
×
Medicine

Are We Better Prepared Now for Another Pandemic? (nymag.com) 221

When it comes to the possibility of a bird flu outbreak, America's Centers for Disease Control recently issued a statement that the risk to the public "remains low."

But even in the event of a worst-case scenario, New York magazine believes "We may be more equipped for another pandemic than you think..." In 2023, more than half of people surveyed said that their lives had not returned to normal since the COVID outbreak, and a surprising number — 47 percent — said they now believe their lives will never return to normal.

But do we really know how a new pandemic would go and how we would handle it? Things are different this time — and in ways that aren't all bad. Unlike with COVID in the spring of 2020, millions of doses of bird-flu vaccines at various stages of testing sit in government stockpiles, and more are on the way. There are also already tests that work, though these are not broadly available to the public... Recent research suggests that we might actually manage a second pandemic better than we would believe. Despite all the noise to the contrary, a June poll by Harvard's School of Public Health says that Americans overall think the government responses to COVID — asking people to wear masks, pausing indoor dining, requiring health-care workers to get vaccinated — were all good ideas. Although the media tends to paint school closures as radically unpopular, only 44 percent of respondents said they currently think the shutdowns were a mistake.

A growing body of research also suggests that many Americans feel stronger for what we endured during the most extreme days of COVID. Counter to what we like to say about our friends and neighbors and children, the challenge of the pandemic may have benefited some people's mental health. One study found that "children entering the pandemic with clinically meaningful mental-health problems experienced notable improvements in their mental health." (Turns out there's one thing worse than shutting down an American school and that's having to attend it.)

The article also points out that "There is no real information" on the likelihood of a bird-flu virus even crossing over into humans.

And of course, "COVID still kills, with a body count just shy of 50,000 Americans in 2024, and it feels like a stretch to say that Americans are particularly concerned."

Are We Better Prepared Now for Another Pandemic?

Comments Filter:
  • What I learned (Score:2, Insightful)

    Public health is in your own hands. If other people want to be risky morons, let them - no amount of evidence will convince them of anything they aren't already primed to believe.

    • Re:What I learned (Score:5, Insightful)

      by grmoc ( 57943 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:27PM (#65048451)

      Sadly, this isn't how it works.

      If others act as disease breeding (and mutation) grounds and communication vectors, then public health cannot be in your own hands.

    • by grmoc ( 57943 )

      Note that this is the reason that we have laws against things like defecating not in a toilet or on someone else's property.
      'cause that crap spreads disease.

      So, you can say it is in your own hands as much as you want, but it isn't true at all so long as you're other than a self-sufficient carveout from all of society (no trading/buying with that society in any dependent way either).

      Practically, that is noone.

    • Re:What I learned (Score:5, Insightful)

      by thegarbz ( 1787294 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @06:52PM (#65048673)

      It absolutely is not. Leaving public health to individuals making individual decisions is precisely how you get disease, how your spread a pandemic, and how you breed drug resistant superbugs. Sure *YOU* may take care of yourself. You may wash your hands. You may not let your animals defecate in your own living room. You may use a full course of antibiotics. But someone else not doing that can have a material affect on your health.

      • by sinij ( 911942 )
        Well, good thing that professionals did such a good job the last time. That how we eliminated COVID in record time by following evidence-driven mitigations and targeted lock downs of vulnerable populations all while allowing populations at minimal risk, like children and young adults, carry on their lives. Then vaccine became available that provided sterilizing immunity and it was all over shortly thereafter. With such success for public health, who and why would look to second-guess them the next time?
        • There was never enough of the population vaccinated well enough at one time to make a global difference. Also if it was all so futile, how did countries like Canada have ten times fewer deaths than per capita than the US?
  • Nope (Score:4, Informative)

    by MpVpRb ( 1423381 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:19PM (#65048417)

    The voters elected the worst president possible

    • by HiThere ( 15173 )

      He's not the worst one possible. Use a bit of imagination.

      • Fine fine, the reanimated corpse of Hitler or an asteroid 10x larger than the dinosaur killer would be marginally worse than Trump, happy?
  • Unlikely (Score:5, Insightful)

    by ArchieBunker ( 132337 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:21PM (#65048433)

    Covid was a hoax by the democrats https://www.nbcnews.com/politi... [nbcnews.com]

    And the head of the health department is an anti vaxxer who had literal brain parasites https://www.pbs.org/newshour/h... [pbs.org]

    We'll be just fine...

  • Politics says no (Score:5, Insightful)

    by grmoc ( 57943 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:25PM (#65048447)

    We could be better prepared.. but the pandemic response was politicized, and so we'll probably see worse outcomes next go round.

  • Nope (Score:5, Insightful)

    by Baron_Yam ( 643147 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:26PM (#65048449)

    At the political level, we do not have the will to do what should be done. At the population level, we don't even have the belief that we should.

    Last time we decided "fuck the old and the sick, if they die they die". And we decided, "I'd rather take my chances than stay away from church and sporting events for a while". And finally, we decided to let people walk around unmasked and unvaccinated as if their freedom was more important than our lives. And instead we focus on minor details as if to prove the whole thing was a hoax.

    These things do not appear to have changed, and if anything we're worse off now than we were before.

  • Yes and No (Score:5, Insightful)

    by JustAnotherOldGuy ( 4145623 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:43PM (#65048489) Journal

    "Are We Better Prepared Now for Another Pandemic? "

    In theory, yes, we should be.

    In reality, probably not.

    In fact, I'm 100% certain that we'll see the same type of idiots spreading the same type of disinformation, just like last time.

    "Masks don't help!" (they do)
    "It's just the flu!" (it's not)
    "Take (horse/dog/sheep medication) and you'll be safe!" (you won't)
    "It's a gubmint plot to control us!" (it's not)
    "It's a hoax!" (it's not)
    "People are dying, but not from it!" (they are)

    You'll see every one of these claims within the first 6 months.

    • by gweihir ( 88907 )

      Definitely. COVID was not deadly enough to really cut down the stupid. Maybe we get lucky and the next thing is.

  • by hdyoung ( 5182939 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:56PM (#65048521)
    Before covid, making and rolling out a new vaccine took like 24 months because it was a hit-or-miss process involving millions of chickens. Nowadays, a competent molecular biologist can design a custom vaccine using software that’s a lot like CAD, order it over the internet, and get a 55-gallon drum of it delivered to next week.

    Ok, that’s an exaggeration but only slightly. There are definitely going to be more pandemics, but the vaccines will show up in a matter of weeks and nothing is likely to close the world the way covid did.
    • by gweihir ( 88907 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @07:11PM (#65048741)

      There are definitely going to be more pandemics, but the vaccines will show up in a matter of weeks and nothing is likely to close the world the way covid did.

      Unless too many people are too stupid to get vaccinated. Then it will be lockdowns again.

      • The public health rationale for lockdowns decreases significantly when there is an effective vaccine.

        • by gweihir ( 88907 )

          No, unfortunately. What decreases is the individual moral rationale, but inly if you ignore indirect effects. Lockdowns are not about protecting individuals. If it was a pure ethical question whether people can protect themselves and lockdowns would serve to protect them when they cannot, you would be right. But that is not the function of lockdowns. Lockdowns are about preventing panic and chaos and keeping society functioning.

          Hence vaccinations only prevent lockdowns when enough people get vaccinated that

    • by HiThere ( 15173 )

      Maybe. A lot of the reason the vaccines were ready so quickly was because COVID was so similar to SARS which they'd gotten ready to build vaccines for, but it turned out to be easy to contain it with quarantines. So if the new disease is similar to something that been studied then they can probably roll it out quickly...if there aren't any problems. (Some vaccines make you MORE sensitive to the disease. Not what you want, but the only way to tell so far it to build a vaccine and test it.)

      It's not a simp

    • Before covid, making and rolling out a new vaccine took like 24 months ... involving millions of chickens.

      Not quite correct. Eggs, not chickens, and some newer techniques that don't use eggs. And it takes months to make a vaccine for a new strain of flu. Prior to COVID-19, the fastest a new vaccine had been developed for a different disease was about four years for measles.

      There are definitely going to be more pandemics, but the vaccines will show up in a matter of weeks and nothing is likely to close the world the way covid did.

      Probably more than weeks. Maybe as little as a year, more or less. First it's necessary to recognize that there is a pandemic, then to identify and characterize the causal agent, then develop the vaccine, then test the vaccine, and then ram

  • than boomer remover at getting rid of folks who think their freedom to get a hair is sacrosanct?
  • by backslashdot ( 95548 ) on Sunday December 29, 2024 @06:46PM (#65048645)

    We'll have massive denials and then blaming of certain racial groups and people will get accused of deliberately poisoning the air and water.

  • And hold on to that feeling, just don't think about this question on January 21st

  • The smart ones are. Prepared to wear masks, prepared to get vaccinated, prepared to keep social distance. The stupid ones will just die massively more frequently than necessary. Somehow I fail to see this as a bad thing.

    • by HiThere ( 15173 )

      It's not clear how deadly bird flu would be if it evolved to be human-human transmissible. This isn't unlikely as it's already cow-cow transmissible, though that suspect that the contagion is via milking-machines. The human-human transmissible version would need a different transmission mechanism.

      OTOH, it is already known to have infected people who were exposed to infected cows. This means that the needed mutation is not a major one. (But how serious is it? This isn't clear. Some people have died of

  • is on a par with a typical flu year. A bad flu year is three times that.

    If the flu isn't a big deal, why is another disease that kills about the same number of people?

    Maybe people are smarter than they're given credit for.

    • 50K is actually a significant outlier at any remotely recent time. The average is closer to 30 +- 10, and the per capita fatality rate has been trending slowly down for a very long time thanks to improved treatments and improved vaccine effectiveness due to improved surveillance, rapid and highly available genetic sequencing and bi/tri/quadrivalent shots (though with the evident extermination of b/yamagata, they're going back to trivalent): https://www.statista.com/stati... [statista.com]
    • Because we don't want additional diseases that kill people? We never had the chance to contain the flu. We had a chance to contain COVID and we blew it.
  • Until we pissed it all away in November. But on the plus side while it's true that we are all significantly more likely to die of bird flu we have a decreased chance of accidentally hitting on a trans chick in a bar so there is that... Got to keep our priorities straight.
  • The United States had more deaths than any other country in the world. And there has been no realistic attempt at an independent investigation of the reasons for that. Just a bunch of partisan internet memes repeated over and over. Which means the next time we will have variations on those same memes repeated over and over again while ignoring the actual results.
  • I hope next pandemic isn't that serious, because nobody going to listen or take it seriously. COVID was mishandled to such catastrophic degree that the very trust in institutions that suppose to protect us in such circumstances is lost, likely for generation or at least decades.
  • We still have a public, and most leaders who think "exponential" means "a lot", so we can't apply policies that control the growth rate. We have a public that fundamentally doesn't understand probability / statistics, and wants everything to be 100% or 0%. We still have leadership that thinks lying to the public to get the desire actions is OK, and then is surprised when they are no longer trusted. We still have big medical industry happy to amplify profits in any situation.

    Maybe if we have an extremely

  • I could not think of a "better" person to handle COVID-like crisis than RFK Jr ...

  • COVID is the new flu, get your shots and go on with your life. I haven't worn a mask out in the public for years now and never have gotten COVID.
  • Covid: a naturally occurring BAT virus that somehow acquired parts of the AIDS virus and a spike cleavage site that facilitated entry by the virus into human cells.

    As for, are we better prepared now for another pandemic. See if anyone has recently patented any new vaccines. Like Fauci patented a Coronavirus vaccine back in March 12, 2020
  • As soon as President Grab 'Em by the Wherever gets his gaggle of quacks in charge of the public health, bird flu will be the least of our worries.

This login session: $13.76, but for you $11.88.

Working...