Journey Towards The Center of the Earth 185
linumax wrote to mention an article detailing an ambitious Japanese-led voyage towards the center of the earth. From the article: "The deep-sea drilling vessel Chikyu made a port call Thursday in Yokohama after ending its first training mission at sea since being built in July at a cost of 500 million dollars. The 57,500-ton Chikyu, which means the Earth in Japanese, is scheduled to embark in September 2007 on a voyage to collect the first samples of the Earth's mantle in human history. The project, led by Japan and the United States with the participation of China and the European Union, seeks clues on primitive organisms that were the forerunners of life and on the tectonic plates that shake the planet's foundations" They also hope to use the information to detect earthquakes more accurately. A 4 page PDF presentation about the Chikyu deep-sea drilling vessel is also available."
Obscure Reference? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Obscure Reference? (Score:2)
or Lord Kinbote!
Re:Obscure Reference? (Score:2)
On the other hand, I don't suppose it would be that hard to get to the middle of the earth, I mean, it's just a few thousand tons... just pull up the blueprints and find the center of the middle deck, and head on over there.
Re:Obscure Reference? (Score:2)
Even more obscure reference (Score:4, Funny)
Best. Science Fiction. Ever.
Re:Even more obscure reference (Score:2)
Yes. A day without Pat Boone is like a day without...night.
I can be more obscure than you can, so nyah (Score:2)
I wonder if they've recently found a stone statuette of some kind of lizard creature?
It gets more obscure... (Score:2)
Did they detect this one? (Score:4, Funny)
Sounds like they just got the idea from a movie (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Sounds like they just got the idea from a movie (Score:2)
Is that the one with the giant bird dictators and the man who says to them - "You can't brainwash me - I'm English!"
If it is then that is one wonderful line.
Re:Sounds like they just got the idea from a movie (Score:2)
Besides, when the relational momentum of said magma changes its direction, it should only affect where the exact locations of the Earth's magnetic poles are.
Re:Sounds like they just got the idea from a movie (Score:2)
Re:Did they detect this one? (Score:2)
Re:Did they detect this one? (Score:2)
Does that count?
Small fix. (Score:2, Funny)
> The proposed program OD21 will evolve into, in close collaboration with the current ODP and international partners, a new international program, named as the Integrated Ocean Drilling Program (IODP), which will use the "CHIKYU" and a U.S. drilling vessel.
Small fix: micro-evolve. No transitional "international program" between Ocean Drilling Programs has ever been found.
Re:Small fix. (Score:2)
Bush cronies jumping on the bandwagon (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Bush cronies jumping on the bandwagon (Score:2)
Re:Bush cronies jumping on the bandwagon (Score:2)
No harm done as long as there are poor mountaineers close-by trying to keep their families fed.
My Bad... (Score:2, Funny)
Yeah, but its still a trillion dollars (Score:2)
Elk are not worth nearly a trillion dollars. Drill ANWR now.
Re:Yeah, but its still a trillion dollars (Score:2)
So no matter how high the price of oil rises on the speculative markets, once we reach this tipping point we are only digging ourselves into a deeper hole.
Besides, petroluem oil is used for many othe
Re:Yeah, but its still a trillion dollars (Score:2)
As to your second point, oil is a product that can be synthesized. Once getting oil out of the ground becomes u
Re:Yeah, but its still a trillion dollars (Score:2)
In my last reply I was mostly pointing out that there is a limit to your statement:
Oil prices are rising and so the economically recoverable part of ANWR rises along with it.
From your reply I can tell you are well aware of this limit, so sorry to belabor the obvious.
Another point I was trying to make is that oil has many uses, and its value is unlikely to decrease, smoothed over the long term. I can picture children in school saying of us a hundred years from now, "You mean those barbarians actually bu
Re:Yeah, but its still a trillion dollars (Score:2)
There's plenty of fingers to point at everyone. I like to think the environmental movement is
Errors Then & Now (Re:...still a trillion doll (Score:2)
As a former contributor to Greenpeace, in my "youthful days", I would agree wholeheartedly with your assessment that the environmental movement is primarily responsible for propagating irrational fear of nuclear power. The depth of their irrationality on the subject was made plain to me by their active opposition to the small radioisotope thermal power sources on deep space missions such as Galileo and Cassini. The most extreme environmentalists made claims like "millions would die" in the case of an accid
Re:Errors Then & Now (Re:...still a trillion d (Score:2)
Re:Errors Then & Now (Re:...still a trillion d (Score:2)
Re:Errors Then & Now (Re:...still a trillion d (Score:2)
We invaded the 2nd largest oil producing nation in the world and gasoline is $2.17 a gallon where I live! What's up with that?
In my own personal worldview, the answer to that question is also an illustration of why I believe democracy is not equivalent to laissez-faire markets. The demand for gasoline is not very elastic (we need to drive to our jobs, deliver goods and services, etc.), and the ratio of consumers to producers is extremely large. This leaves the producers fr
Re:ANWR oil is a stop-gap measure at best... (Score:2, Funny)
I'm glad ... (Score:2, Funny)
Re:I'm glad ... (Score:2)
The Atheist Agenda (Score:5, Funny)
Neo-Darwinist heathens! There is only ONE "forerunner" of life on this planet, and that's GOD!
Re:The Atheist Agenda (Score:5, Informative)
It was the Flying Spaghetti Monster, you insensitive clod!
Re:The Atheist Agenda (Score:2, Interesting)
Just a thought.
Re:The Atheist Agenda (Score:2)
Re:The Atheist Agenda (Score:2)
Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:5, Funny)
Ever see a pop can with a small hole in it? I mean, do they really have a clue what might happen if they provide a channel for deep magma flows to rise? Sure, it's a little sci-fi doomsday scenario, but I'd hate to be the one who signed off on the risk assessment for this project.
Scientist 1: Hey, Jimmie, remember that movie we saw when we were kids? The one where they go to the center of the earth?
Scientist 2: Sure, why'dya ask?
Scientist 1: I got this reasearch grant and I thought we could drill down to see if those giant mushrooms were real.
Scientest 2: Sure, I'm in.
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:2)
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:2)
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:2)
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:2)
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:2)
What I'm curious about is what causes the bubble of magma to form...
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:2)
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Detecting quakes? What about causing them? (Score:2)
Journey to the center of the earth? (Score:5, Insightful)
Center of the Earth? (Score:2, Informative)
Mantle != Core
Mantle Rock on the Surface (Score:2)
There's a valley in western Newfoundland where, on east side, the soil is derived from weathered crust material. On the west side, the 'soil' is mantle rock.
I've driven along a road in the bottom of the valley and the difference is striking! The east side is heavily overgrown. The west side has only a few blades of grass that seem to be growing in tiny pockets containing soil blown across the valley.
So, no drilling re
Re:Center of the Earth? (Score:2)
Re:Center of the Earth? (Score:2)
Nope - one last bit to demolish. He wants the electricity to power Air Conditioning. Well most A/C will work by running cooler air over/through hot parts of your vehicle and there is precious little cool air available in the mantle. The alternative would be to expell a compressed refrigerant gas. I have no idea how much you would need to keep cool down there, but I certain we're talking Hollywood physics.
Sorry GP, I don't think it's going to work. If you really want to get to the centre of the Earth, yo
I've always wondered... (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:I've always wondered... (Score:4, Informative)
A major problem they will encounter is the plasticity of rocks as the approach the mantle -- the heat and pressure allows rocks to flow, much like silly putty will ooze. That plasticity make it difficult to maintain an open well for the bit to drill through.
Re:I've always wondered... (Score:5, Informative)
Mantle rock consists of olivines, different pyroxenes and other mafic minerals. Typified by peridotite, dunite, and eclogite, mantle rocks also possesses a higher portion of iron and magnesium and a smaller portion of silicon and aluminium than the crust. In the mantle, temperatures range between 100C at the upper boundary to over 3,500C at the boundary with the core. Although these temperatures far exceed the melting points of the mantle rocks at the surface, particularly in deeper ranges, they are almost exclusively solid. The enormous lithostatic pressure exerted on the mantle prevents them from melting.
They won't come out in China... (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:They won't come out in China... (Score:2)
Re:They won't come out in China... (Score:2)
Re:They won't come out in China... (Score:2)
Thanks for the google maps hack information. My current hole would have ended up 2 miles off-coast of Sydney, Australia and with me drowning after being shark-bit if it weren't for current technology setting me straight.
Re:They won't come out in China... (Score:2)
When you correct your aim best not to aim for the beach in Sydney, the people there are worse than sharks. They are a bit touchy about immigrants at the moment. The mind boggles to think what they would do to somebody tunneling into one of their beaches.
Re:They won't come out in China... (Score:2)
Damn, I was shooting for +1 Subtle as I didn't think many would relate it to Cronulla Beach. Oh well.
Parent is an idiot (Score:2)
Then again, maybe it's an IE thing?
Hayabusa... (Score:2, Funny)
Any life in the mantle? (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Any life in the mantle? (Score:2)
Re:Any life in the mantle? (Score:2)
Cthulu?
Rumored Replenishment of Oil Flelds (Score:2)
Of course, murphy's law says that if so, they will replenish at a rate at a rate matching our correct consumption divided by 2. Meaning we will still be up the creek without a paddle.
The first samples ... (Score:2, Insightful)
Solution to Peak Oil? (Score:5, Interesting)
This may be slightly off-topic. but it seems to me that if we improve drilling technology enough to breach the Earth's Mantle, there lies an almost endless supply of heat energy. According to http://zebu.uoregon.edu/ph162/l18.html [uoregon.edu], the average thermal gradient is 30 degrees C per kilometer, so that at a depth of 20,000 feet, the temperature is 190 degrees C. The problem is that in solids the heat can only be replenished by diffusion, so that steam extraction of heat would occur faster than the heat can be replenished. However, if we could dig deep enough to where heat could be replenished by convection, then the concept of geothermal heat extraction could be feasible.
Another alternative that may currently be feasible is to detonate small H-bombs in deep cavities to replenish the heat. This, in fact, was already done in the PACER project, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PACER [wikipedia.org]. The major problem in the Pacer project was the reliance of plutonium fission bombs to initiate the fusion reaction, which created problems with radioactive waste. If a "Fusion Fuse" other than fission could be devised, we could dispense with esoteric, far-in-the-future methods of controlling fusion above ground, and simply use deep cavities in the Earth to release heat via uncontrolled fusion reactions, and extract the heat.
Bottom Line: I am not buying into the "Peak Oil Doomsday Scenario" http://www.lifeaftertheoilcrash.net/Index.html [lifeaftertheoilcrash.net] just yet.
Re:Solution to Peak Oil? (Score:2)
Another alternative that may currently be feasible is to detonate small H-bombs in deep cavities to replenish the heat.
Why not just run some nuke plants? The newer generation of plant could probably run for 1000 years on the available uranium reserves.
Re:Solution to Peak Oil? (Score:2)
According to the projections of Uranium reserves on this page, conventional nuclear power won't get us very far: http://www.financialsense.com/fsu/editorials/petc h /2005/0703.html [financialsense.com]
Also, conventional nuclear fission plants still have the problem of creating highly radioactive waste products with very long half-lifes, so the infrastructure must be very expensive for safety reasons, and there is still the disposal problem
However,if we ever get past the "pilot plant" stage in designing and building breeder r
Re:Solution to Peak Oil? (Score:2)
Also, conventional nuclear fission plants still have the problem of creating highly radioactive waste products with very long half-lifes, so the infrastructure must be very expensive for safety reasons, and there is still the disposal problem
Some of the designs covered inthe latest SciAm improve efficiency by a factor of 20 and reduce the waste to a 500 year problem (with less hazard in the interim). This is what I base my claims on. It has the advantage that it can easily break down Pu from weapons, whi
Re:Takes time to build nuke plants (Score:5, Interesting)
An intersting example: I recently watched a documentary on the "Little Ice Age". Between 1300 to around 1900, the climate in Northern Europe and Eastern North America became dramatically colder. Before that time, vineyards in England flourished, and English wine was considered superior to French wine. Cereal grains were the main crop. The Vikings colonized Greenland. But after the climate shift, the crops failed repeatedly, leading to widespread famine. Eventually, the potato was introduced from the Americas. The potato was much better suited to the climatic conditions of the time, but people refused to cultivate it. Priests called it "the devil's root". Eventually, the Germans were the first to adopt the potato, during the 30 years war, but only because the crop could not be burned by invading armies. The French did not adopt the potato, and famines persisted, partially contributing to the French Revolution.
So people suffered and starved for hundreds of years, simply because of their inability to adapt their culture to the changing environment.
Will we do any better?
Re:Takes time to build nuke plants (Score:2)
So people suffered and starved for hundreds of years, simply because of their inability to adapt their culture to the changing environment.
Although you didn't blame them exclusively, Europe's relative secularism has taken care of priests saying or doing stupid things like that. I'd like to think that the US could be included in that but Creationism makes me very pessimistic on that score.
I'm a bit of a misanthrop
nuke plants and cultural flexibility (Score:2)
In studying religious belief systems, what it the difference between a "crazy cult" and a "real religion"? As far as I can discern, the only answer seems to be the number of followers of that belief system: if more than a few thousand followers, then it "must" be a religion.
The U.S. has always been a breeding ground for cult-like, splinter-group protestant sects. Most often, these sects would form around some charismatic leader, remain localized, and then gradually die off. An unforeseen side effect of i
Re:Takes time to build nuke plants (Score:2)
In #14279307, Sayeth deaddrunk,
Although you didn't blame them exclusively, Europe's relative secularism has taken care of priests saying or doing stupid things like that. I'd like to think that the US could be included in that but Creationism makes me very pessimistic on that score.
I do not think I can respond to your observation any more eloquently and succinctly than this quote by famous literary critic Harold Bloom from his article "Reflections in the Evening Land" [guardian.co.uk] in yesterday's edition of The Gua [guardian.co.uk]
Re:Solution to Peak Oil? (Score:2)
The way I see it, it will not be very long before society will have to begin to change dramatically in order to survive without experiencing a die-back or series of world wars.
Yachts are fine, as long as they are sailing ships, but SUVs will be gone. The globalized economy will mostly be a vestige, and industry will return to our
lifeafterthe oilcrash.net (Score:2)
Your idea to start drilling now isn't going to work unless you can figure out where to drill. The industry dosn't know where... they are drilling what they do know about.
Savinar is out to lunch simply fanning flames. In the short term he is correct - and there is likely to be a
Re:lifeafterthe oilcrash.net (Score:2)
It's not just the benefit of pleasant driving. Think of how much oil is used in asphalt. Not to mention how much is used by the construction vehicles themselves.
Long-distance freight traffic travelling by truck is ridiculous; it should all b
Those pesky kanji... (Score:2, Informative)
(if that didn't work, try this one: http://www5.big.or.jp/~otake/hey/kanji/gifmoji/f5/ chikyuu.gif [big.or.jp])
where the first one is read "chi", meaning earth (in the dirt sense). The second is read "kyuu" and means "ball".
So. Welcome to my planet, dirtball.
Another Glomar Explorer? (Score:2, Funny)
Okay, who lost the submarine [wikipedia.org] THIS time?
Tinfoil Hat: Off
Calling CleverNickName! (Score:2)
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0202314/ [imdb.com]
you could be a consultant!
DG
Captain Obvious Says.... (Score:2)
Predicting earthquakes? A Breakthrough(TM) indeed...
Scott Adams quote... (Score:2, Funny)
Four words... (Score:2)
My prediction (Score:2, Funny)
Craft Name (Score:2)
I realize I'm going to come off as a petty nitpicker, but couldn't they have done a better job of Romanizing the name of the craft? It needs one more 'u' (I checked the original Japanese). Without the second 'u', it just looks downright wrong to me.
Incidentally, "chikyuu" means "Earth" in Japanese, which I think is a great name for the craft.
Question about the center of the Earth (Score:2)
Just curious....
Re:Question about the center of the Earth (Score:2)
Yes, because all the mass in the earth is pulling in different directions. It cancels out.
But you will get a hell of a lot of pressure trying to cave your habitat in. I think a large part of the gross density of the earth is caused by pressure squeezing the iron core until its density increases by 20% or so.
Re:Question about the center of the Earth (Score:2)
At the exact centre of the earth you have zero gravity in the sense that the attraction to mass is equal in all directions and cancels out. However if you create a really large "house" let's say with a diameter of a few thousand kilometers you would get (micro-)gravity: welcome to the hollow earth theories.
Don't ask me exactly how big this "house" would have to be before the gravity of the mass "below" you is significantly greater than the mass "above" you (which is
Re:Question about the center of the Earth (Score:2)
I hope they know what they're doing... (Score:4, Funny)
I hope they've really thought this through, 'cause to me it sounds sooooo not worth the risk.
Implications for global warming (Score:2)
Re:That drill bit better ... (Score:2, Funny)
Because, as we all know, the mantle is spinning at a high RPM, thus acting as a gyroscope, providing stability to the earth.
Re:That drill bit better ... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:That drill bit better ... (Score:3, Informative)
Re:thin crust, extra cheese (Score:3, Informative)
Better yet, they do (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:they better be carefull (Score:5, Insightful)
Sorry to be a party pooper, not a troll though. All this fun about what they might hit is a bit over done. The depth of drilling is 25,000 feet. That is a bad joke. They drill 31,000 feet in South Alabama all the time. They drill nearly 50,000 feet at Petronius 65 miles south of Alabama. What they have hit doesn't in any way resemble the "mantle" and I really doubt this project is ever going close to the "mantle."
This rig might do a somewhat useful drilling of fault zones and it might find other useful things but this isn't likely to be of any use in actual "mantle" research.
The Russians have drilled locations much deeper and attempted to go into the mantle. They hit hot salt water in the rock but nothing resembling the "mantle" that we all have been so rigorously taught to believe exists. Actually so many deep bores of the earth exist around the world that vastly exceed this depth it seems to me almost useless to consider this "research." Maybe we should be considering exactly what the research is actually going to be? I wouldn't hazard a guess but unless the ship is going to bore something like 200,000 feet the prospects of really new research coming from it are dubious. The world is full of holes going down 25,000 feet.
My suspicion is that they will find if they drill fault zones a pretty shocking reality that they knew nothing of what was going on. It would be a fair prediction to estimate that these zones are water penetration zones. The seismic signature of a "diving plate" is probably only a water penetration crack into the rocks below. This would explain the volcanoes and all without any of the subduction or other stuff. Such a discovery would have the science of Geology scratching their heads for a long time. They might discover that the earths plates match (as they do!) in the Pacific as well as the Atlantic. They might discover like Yukos found that there is "Magma oil." They might just come up with a bunch of other fun stuff. Again they might not but who knows? It could be a lot of fun watching.
Re:Where is Art Bell when you need him? (Score:2)