60 Years Later: The V2 And The Space Race 196
securitas writes "In a two-part feature written sixty years after the V2 rocket was first launched on London, BBC News Online's Paul Rincon describes the Soviet-American space race, German V2 rocket technology and how the USSR and USA divided Germany's best scientists between them. The second part addresses the technological lineage of both space programs, the creation of NASA, intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) development and the V2's legacy. Another feature provides some context, following the history of the development of the V2 rocket from its precursors that began with space flight enthusiasts like Wernher von Braun and Walter Riedel, through its use as a terrifying weapon in the London Blitz, to the recruitment drive by the Americans and Soviets. Today the V2 rocket is being used as the basis for the Canadian Arrow X Prize team. The Arrow team has some pages on V2 history and the main engine thrust chamber. For those interested you can read more at the A4 / V2 Rocket Resource site."
Nazi Germany (Score:3, Insightful)
Never forget that.
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:5, Insightful)
Antropomorphisms like this are dangerous. It's so tempting to say "Russia wants to conquer Tschetschenya" or "USA want to justify Guantanamo to the public opinion", but you should always remember there is no such person as Uncle Sam or Mother Russia. Whatever George W. Bush wants or needs, it's not necessarily what every American or even majority of Americans want or need. It's also dangerous when you talk about dictatorship, as there was more in Third Reich than just Hitler and his crazy followers. What we know about Werner von Braun is that he was interested in rocket science "as such" - his lifelong dream was a manned mission to Mars [space.com]. He worked for Hitler not because he loved him, but simply because for a German rocket scientist in 1940's there weren't really any other options. When you say "That was their ethos" you should consider who do you mean by "they". Them-Nazis? Sure, you're right. Them-German scientitst? You are obviously wrong.
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
It was more of a different mindset... (Score:2, Informative)
And it's definately not an American thin
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
um...where? I'm sure everyone realizes you're talking about Chechnya or (Slashdot is filtering out my windows-1251 encoded chars) and not some German republic somewhere, but I thought I would point it out so no one is confused.
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2, Informative)
a quick search on him revealed that he tried to differ between "jewish physics" (theroretical) and "arayan physics" (experimental).
he also referred to heisenberg and planck as "white jews".
i'm also pretty sure he would have spelled "Nationalsozialismus" with a "z".
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2, Insightful)
Anyway, was there anything incorrect [wiesenthal.com] about what the grandparent said?
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
unfortunately it is impossible to remember all the racist crap that was said throughout history.
but fyi: my other reply [slashdot.org] to your revisionist post further up was completely out of memory. i'm german, so i don't need a spell checker to know how to spell "Nationalsozialismus".
do you have any comments on that?
an interesting comment (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:3, Interesting)
Churchill wanted to drop chemical weapons on German cities in retaliation for the V1/V2 raids, but fortunately was persuaded against it. If the Germans had used chemical
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Yeah. Pretty good for war criminals using slave labour.
The US protected war criminal von Braun in order to outrace the Soviets.
A (possibly apocryphal) story goes that one time after the war, von Braun's plane, flying from Europe to the US, developed mechanical troubles and the pilot was about to divert to England, when von Braun informed him that he, von Braun, was still subject to arrest in the U
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:3, Insightful)
The Nazi regime ruled Germany through terror tactics. Without doubt, the attacks on the German industral base were founded and necessary attacks to cripple the industrial power of the German State. The attack on Dresden (a protected city and a refugee camp) was not necessary, nor was it honorable. We hi
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Sources? Coventry was in 1941, Dresden in 1945. I can't see that the one had anything directly to do with the other - 4 years is a long time to be angry when there was so much other stuff going on, including much other bombing of German cities in the meantime.
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
It's just another shining example of US hypocrisy. War criminals are OK, if they have something to offer. It doesn't matter what they've done in the past, apparently.
And you didn't c
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Pan
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
Re:Nazi Germany (Score:2)
von Braun would have been working on rockets regardless of Nazis in power or not. The difference is that the Nazis prohibited civilian research on rocketry (prohibiting the "Verein fuer Raumschiffahrt").
Another point is that all those people (von Braun, Einstein, Born, Hilbert, Minkowski, Heisenberg...) are products of an education of pre-Nazi Germany.
Not to mention all those people who worked in Germany, because of those outstanding scientists.
Before the Nazi-regime, practically all papers in Chemis
If this is your cup of tea... (Score:4, Informative)
Re:If this is your cup of tea... (Score:2)
you didn't miss much - but i still can't believe that after making it thru the first 700 odd pages you gave up so close to the end. sure it's a rambling shaggy dog tale, but it's much less boring that american psycho.
Re:If this is your cup of tea... (Score:3, Funny)
Hey! Fickt nicht mit der Raketemensch! Seriously, though, I read GR about 10 times, and it made more sense (and was more enjoyable and impressive) each time, except for the 8th. :-)
my parents (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:my parents (Score:2, Informative)
Re:my parents (Score:5, Informative)
Ever heard a mortar shell hitting something? It hasnt ANY kind of engine, but you can hear the whine of the projectile 10-20 seconds before impact
Re:my parents (Score:3, Funny)
Sub launched V2? (Score:2)
Re:Sub launched V2? (Score:3, Interesting)
Even if used at short range, the V2 was never "accurate". It had extremely primitive guidance, and was no better than throwing a dart at a
Re:Sub launched V2? (Score:2)
Re:Sub launched V2? (Score:3, Insightful)
High altitude bombers had similar accuracy, and it usually took countless thousands of bombs per raid to effectively destroy major targets. Each large bomber raid carried more explosive power than the all V2s comb
Re:Sub launched V2? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:Sub launched V2? (Score:2, Insightful)
Except that it didn't work. I've never seen anybody suggest that Great Britain considered surrendering due to fear of the V2.
The Germans were WAY ahead of their time in weapons development
Yes, and they dedicated so many resources into this not-yet-effective weapons system that it hastened their defeat. With the guidance systems of the 40s-60s, missiles w
Re:Sub launched V2? (Score:2)
They were working on it. (Score:3, Interesting)
another project the US picked up and pursued.
Scud (Score:3, Interesting)
Scud - link with more detail (Score:4, Informative)
The best Germans (Score:4, Funny)
Re:The best Germans (Score:5, Interesting)
They might be a bit deluded when they think of themselves as a master race (well, only some of them do) but if they were to qualify it as a "master engineering race" then I think there'd be a lot less of us that would argue with it. From rockets to cars, they are excellent engineers.
If you are interested in "our" Germans from the parent's statement, do a google on "operation paperclip". It's very interesting... the US program to extract as many German scientists out of post-Nazi Germany as possible.
-- james
PS I mean to stir no racial tension by the use of "master race", merely referring to the use of a very well known phrase
Re:The best Germans (Score:3, Funny)
Re:The best Germans (Score:2, Funny)
I AM AN EXCELLENT ENGINEER! I am an excellent engineer! By genetics!!!1!! I genetically r00l!11! Imagine a Beowulf cluster of myself!!!11!! My engineering genes racially own you!
Hey wait, my car... broke down... yesterday..
Re:The best Germans (Score:3, Insightful)
I assure you, right now there are no more people in Germany thinking of themselves as the "master race" than there are people in the US thinking of their nation as superior to others.
Oh, wait...
Re:The best Germans (Score:3, Interesting)
Yes, a lot of our technol
Re:The best Germans (Score:2, Informative)
nonsense.
being a member of the "master race [wikipedia.org]" was inherited by "blood".
there were tests based on physical characteristics to determine the percentage of "purity".
Re:The best Germans (Score:2, Informative)
Reason why: Sergei P. Korolev. (Score:5, Informative)
People forget that the Soviet rocket program in a very secret group called RNII was very underestimated by everyone else, because in the 1930's before the Yezhovchina Great Purge the Russians probably had some of the most advanced rocket development programs in the world--in some cases more advanced than the German programs at the time! Despite the Great Purge, Korolev managed to keep the majority of his development team at RNII together, and Korolev was actually working for SMERSH (Soviet counterintelligence) in the latter half of the 1940's studying German developments in rocket technology. That's why by the early 1950's the Soviet rocket program was probably more advanced than the US program, and that's why they were able to build the R-7 rocket designed by Korolev's team (which was far larger than any US equivalent rocket at the time) that carried the large-sized Soviet nuclear bombs with the side benefit of being able to launch payloads into orbit. The sheer size of the R-7 was also the reason why the Russians were able to launch unmanned probes around the Moon and launch the first manned flights. Because the R-7 was designed as an ICBM, it meant the ability to launch in a fairly short countdown sequence and used launch pads that could erect the rocket into firing position fairly quickly, too; that's why the Russians were able to launch reconnaissance satellites so quickly and had a pretty advanced space weapons program.
Re:Reason why: Sergei P. Korolev. (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:The best Germans (Score:2)
The Visionary.... (Score:5, Informative)
In the early 1940's, he wrote a letter to president Franklin D. Roosevelt urging him to start a project to build an atomic bomb because the German government had already started a little atomic bomb project of their own. Einstein believed that a weapon of mass destruction in the hands of the United States would not only end the war, but ensure safety to the rest of the world after the war as well. Roosevelt, being a believer in Einstein, became thrilled at this letter and took the plea into deep consideration. Soon, the project was underway.
Re:The Visionary.... (Score:5, Informative)
Your assumption.
His only fear was, that the Nazi would build them. He didn't believe in the US being the saviour of the world. In fact, he was suspicous towards any kind of patriotism or nationalism.
They really were after rocket scientists (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:They really were after rocket scientists (Score:2)
Re:They really were after rocket scientists (Score:2)
Basically, yeah, same thing. Just like there was no point in taking as a POW some lowly mechanic, likewise the US army didn't really have any reason to arrest a talking head. That late in both wars, the fighting was over and neither of those guys were "fighters" anyway.
Re:They really were after rocket scientists (Score:2)
Which would mean his first chance to surrender would have been when he crossed the Finnish border into the Soviet Union. There was no bridge between Sweden and Denmark at the time (and if there were, it would have been bombed to hell). Which is moot, since...
"The Americans were at Penemunde (sp?) and he tried to surrender to them."
... Peenemünde is on an island. If nothing else, the US would have been very interested in his uber-
Re:They really were after rocket scientists (Score:2)
Wernher von Braun (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Wernher von Braun (Score:5, Informative)
Von Braun did say
'Once the rockets are up, who cares where they come down?
That's not my department'.
It was even put into a 1965 song by Tom Lehrer [aol.com]:
Gather 'round while I sing you of Wernher von Braun,
A man whose allegiance
Is ruled by expedience.
Call him a Nazi, he won't even frown,
'Ha, Nazi, Schmazi,' says Wernher von Braun.
Don't say that he's hypocritical,
Say rather that he's apolitical.
'Once the rockets are up, who cares where they come down?
That's not my department,' says Wernher von Braun.
Some have harsh words for this man of renown,
But some think our attitude
Should be one of gratitude,
Like the widows and cripples in old London town,
Who owe their large pensions to Wernher von Braun.
You too may be a big hero,
Once you've learned to count backwards to zero.
"In German oder English I know how to count down,
Und I'm learning Chinese!" says Wernher von Braun.
Does not compute... (Score:3, Insightful)
.
WTF? The Russians get into space and later on the space race is on? Hadn't the russians won (by being first into space?)
Re:Does not compute... (Score:2)
But today is my birthday and the anniversary of Kennedy's man on the moon speech.
Also Kennedy's wedding day, which makes you wonder why he wanted to fly to the moon
Re:Does not compute... (Score:2)
Re:Does not compute... (Score:2)
Nazi tech (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Nazi tech (Score:2)
Nuclear weapons
Computers
RADAR
Supersonic 20,000lb bombs
Jet aircraft (before the Germans)
Seemingly unbreakable encryption (even today)
Sure, the Germans came up with lots, but it was only their V2 program that was of any interest to anyone after the war. The main Allied inventions had serious and far-reaching implications for technology after the war, and even today.
Re:Nazi tech (Score:2, Insightful)
Nuclear weapons
True
Computers
Nope, Konrad Zuse of germany was first. However the Nazis failed to take advantage of it.
RADAR
Both sides had radar before the war, the achievement of the british was the magnetron, enable extremely high power and high frequency radar.
Supersonic 20,000lb bombs
They were just scaled up conventional bombs. I fail too see the achievement. May also be interesting to note that the allies did not have any targets for 20,000lb bombs on their side.
Re:Nazi tech (Score:5, Informative)
Encryption technology (only comprimised due to physical reasons, i.e. someone stole one)
Sorry ,but your last statement is utter Bullshit.Either you dont know about encryption or are trolling.The inventor of Enigma assumed that a working Enigma would be available to the enemy and therefore,attempted to build the security around the Algorithm.
In fact ,when the machine's blueprints reached the french they considered the enigma to be unbreakable and thats why they passed the details to the Polish.A young Mathematician named Marion Rewjyski(sp?) set to work on cracking enigma.
For details read the book by
Simon Singh [amazon.co.uk].
It was the poles who first broke the enigma and Bletchley park,which came in later, decoded the intercepts
The Enigma was the most advanced encryption system at its time in the world but to say it was broken only because a machine was captured is utter fallacy.
P.S I didnt mean to be rude but most /. ers have read enough articles on Encryption to know that the security of a cipher is in its algorithm and nowhere else.
Re:Nazi tech (Score:2, Informative)
... and smart bombs (Score:2)
Although never deployed they did experiment with wire guided smart bombs which did work. I saw this BBC doco years back called "The Secret War" or something similar, about secret weapons etc in WW2. Among the amazing stuff was film of a smart bomb test using a dummy bomb on a target building, direct bulls-eye. Also they had a clip showing that in the Battle of the Bulge the Reich was trying to deploy one of its experimental jet bombers, holy sh*t eh, just as well the weather was no good.
Had some very cleve
For more information.... (Score:5, Interesting)
It is one of the few places on Earth where you can see an intact V1 and V2 rocket.
Re:For more information.... (Score:2)
Canadian content (Score:4, Insightful)
Most of the engineers who worked at Avro went to work for the US space program. Yet again picking the best scientists from the spoils of, this time, a political war.
It boggles the mind all those connections.
If you're in Canada visiting mention "Avro Arrow" and see what reaction you get even now all these years later.
Arrow info [avroarrow.org]
Re:Canadian content (Score:4, Interesting)
EXN.ca [www.exn.ca] an article on the Canadian Discovery Channel about the relationship between Avro Arrow and NASA.
"When they were flying the Arrow," explains Gainor, "they decided that only one person should talk to the pilot, and that person should have experience as a pilot. At NASA, to this day, all the conversations with the crew are done through the capcom, which is always another astronaut."
The Avro Incident (Score:2)
Most of the engineers who worked at Avro went to work for the US space program. Yet again picking the best scientists from the spoils of, this time, a political war.
It boggles the mind all those connections.
If you're in Canada visiting mention "Avro Arrow" and see what reaction you
Re:The Avro Incident (Score:2)
You say that as if Canada were a sovereign nation and not part of the United States.
Gravity's Rainbow (Score:2)
I think fair use will stretch enough to allow me to quote one of his "Rocket Limericks" :
There once was a thing called a V2
To pilot which you did not need to
You just pushed a button
And it would leave nothing But stiffs and big holes and debris too
Re:Gravity's Rainbow (Score:2, Informative)
BTW, during my days in university I studied in the same building that German scientists worked in after the ww2 on designing soviet jets and rockets in Himki near Moscow . These were the buildings of Lavochkin Association company ( the one which built famous La-5 during ww2 then the company developed first russian jets and later produced russian space vehicles which flew to Moon Mars and Venus).
Astronaut Gordon Cooper wrote about this ... (Score:3, Interesting)
p. 172 "As we always said at the time, our Germans are better than their Germans.
"The visitors to Wehrner's house included
p. 173: "At war's end, a manned V-2 was sitting on the pad at Peenemunde, all tested out, fueled up, and ready to go. It would have been launched on a low-energy easterly orbit, Jack explained. The plan: to drop a warhead on New York City. That 1945 manned rocket flight -- sixteen years before the first U.S. manned rocket flight -- came within a week or so of being launched."
"Wehrner confided to me that the Germans were testing more than rockets at Peenemunde. "Some of the craft we were developing," he said, "were far ahead of anything the rest of the world had or knew about."
p. 170: After a V-2 first hit London, Wehrner remarked to his colleagues, "the rocket worked perfectly, except for landing on the wrong planet."
First V2 sightings (Score:3, Interesting)
Read more at Linus Walleij's site [df.lth.se] covering the topic. Interesting reading.
Re:Launched where? (Score:2)
Re:Launched where? (Score:2)
Re:Launched where? (Score:2)
Re:Launched where? (Score:2)
Of course, his ignorance of history didn't stop him from posting in the first place, so we can all breath a little easier.
Re:Does it mention (Score:2)
I've always thought that was a little unfair of us. Sure, they committed a grave moral crime in using concentration camp labor, but it's very convenient of us to only care about that after we've used them for every bit of knowledge and skill they had and the space program was on coast. If the information had become public in the 50s or 60s, I imagine the government w
Re:Does it mention (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Does it mention (Score:2)
No, I'm not trolling and I don't have time to get into the argument about wheter scientific knowledge carries a stain from the way it was acquired - that one could run and run.
Re:Does it mention (Score:2)
Does He-4 denote a preference to pepsi over coke... if so maybe W-184 means someone may vote conservative and Au-197 could mean that someone is inclined to be biased in favour of wearing boxers rather than jocks.
Re:Does it mention (Score:2)
Re:Does it mention (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Insightful? (Score:2)
Re:Does it mention (Score:2)
Re:Does it mention (Score:2)
But to amplify your comment, countless lives were saved because many slave laborers actively sabotaged production. Slave laborers in munition factories that survived the war reported that they did all they could to deliver duds.
North Koreans already have ballistic missiles (Score:4, Informative)
Further information on North Korean missile programs here [fas.org]
Re:nazis (Score:2)
Strictly speaking the first part only can be credited to von Braun. Mort Sahl added the second bit.
Re:nazis (Score:2, Informative)
"I aim at the stars, but sometimes I hit London."
-- Mort Sahl, who, incidentally, happens to be Jewish.
Re:Sputnik /= Basketball (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Sputnik /= Basketball (Score:2)
Re:Working for Uncle Joe (Score:2, Informative)
why doesn't Korolev get the same political backslash von Braun does
maybe because Korolev himself spent years in Gulag.