Posted
by
michael
from the diving-in-to-capitalism dept.
0biJon writes "The BBC says 'For as little as $20,000, you could soon have a letter sent to a new "post office" aboard the International Space Station (ISS) and back care of the Russian space agency.' Maybe Lance Bass can mail himself up?"
This discussion has been archived.
No new comments can be posted.
Is this a joke or just some stupid ploy to get money for the Russian space program. I mean, 20k...that's an expensive letter.
What would the point be except for rich people to claim that they spent 20k on a stamp basically. I know of some crappy fundraisers, but this one sucks.
I'd rather them just ask for donations really. It'd be more honerable I think.
I'm sure that you could just donate money, but obviously people aren't doing that. I don't really see this as much different then donating to a charity and getting a small gift.
The ashes are on a one way trip. The letter ain't.
So $5,300 x 2 = $20k?
If only NASA ran an airline--then I could buy my one-way ticket home for 1/4 of the price instead of purchasing the (currently cheaper) round trip ticket.
You don't get to send much
"Celestis will place cremated remains into personalized flight capsules that can hold approximately one-quarter ounce (7 grams) of ashes"
It's a symbolic act.
I'm guessing that your letters will weigh a bit more
# Delivery of one kilo of cargo to the ISS: $10-20,000
# Return of one kilo from the ISS to Earth: $60,000
# Cost of one hour's work by the team aboard the ISS: $18-19,000
"Cost of one hour's work by the team aboard the ISS: $18-19,000"???? does this mean i have to pay for the post and the time to read it?? or does it mean i can pay an extra 20g's to have them do what ever i want? id donate to a fund to have lance take an hour space walk w/ no space suit!
But, if you want to save $2K and achieve the same result...
1. Put Lance in an envelope with the sender's address as "Space Station, Earh Orbit" 2. Mail him to your own address 3. Refuse to accept him and send him back to the post office 4. The PO will send the mail back to the original sender, i.e. the Space Station
Well, that would require postage. A better way is to put your address as the destination, and the ISS as the sender, but don't put postage on it. Seeing as how the letter had no postage, the post office would send it "back to the sender"
I'm not sure if that works anymore, but I remember reading about how someone did this and they succeeded in mailing something, without postage, to one of their friends in the same city.
If a letter costs $20k, a catalog will be a lot more. It might be cheaper to pay the $20 Million to have it hand delivered. Maybe by one of the models:).
I'm thinking masterbation in space must be a messy thing
Additionally, you always get a push in the opposite direction of where you noodle is pointing to (impulse laws). As Stanislaw Lem noted in "The Fiasco" (*): The perfect murder in space would be to place a naked person in the middle of a room, hovering. He mentioned that you have to be sure that that person has an empty digesting system and an empty bladder. The person would simply starve to death without any opportunity to reach the walls. He seem t
> One question is whether the $20,000 for the stamp is merely an additional cost, or if it includes the cost of transporting a kilogram or so of cargo.
Sounds like someone's thinking about becoming the system's first astrodealer. You reckon they smoke a lot of pot on the ISS?
just the symbolic act of your LETTER having travelled to iss and back.
and that's it. just a way to get financed, and a way to give something symbolic back to the people donating, making the donating much 'easier' for cheapskate-minded people with lot of money.
those numbers were there for so that you could try to calculate the PROFIT they get from the letter, and if it was worth it for the russians to sell such service. it costs THEM $10-20,000 per kilo, $60,000 to return that kilo, and $18-19,000 per hours work of astro/cosmonauts.
Probably an ounce. Or it's metric equivalent (28.35 grams). So, one first class stamp for the first 28.35 grams, $20,000. Whats it cost for each additional gram?
For that cost, I think I'd go with DMT instead of THC.
"The check's in the mail. It's probably still on the launch pad. I mailed it in plenty of time, though."
I shudder to think of the kind of bills you'd need to have a $20-$30K stamp be a cost effective stalling method. I doubt they'd launch your letter before their check clears, at least.
Do you think you could use one of those business reply envelopes (postage to be paid by addressee) to send your junk mail offers back via the ISS and thereby really stick it to that bank that keeps offering you the 0.01% VISA card?
Maybe we can send through the ISS a couple (or several hundred) of those postage to be paid by addressee to spam king Alan Ralsky much like the people who signed him up for real junk mail in this/. this article [slashdot.org].
Imagine the dismay on the senders face when their galactic letter comes back with "Return To Sender" on the envelope:) For 20,000 bucka you better make damn sure that the letter is addressed correctly!!
There's absolutely no way for them to prove whether they sent it up to space or not. They could just burnbag the mail and you would never know. Even if they did send it to space, would you expect a reply?
Assuming they did send it to space, would you get refunded if the letter was on a shuttle that had a Columbia-like disaster?
I'll bet God and Santa Claus are on some very rich kids' space-mailing-lists now. Of course, in God's case, the letters shouldn't come back down, just get jettisonned Simpsons-style.
I once had a package pass through New Jersey on its way from Sacramento to Seattle. But through the ISS? I'd like a screenshot of that tracking history.
Sacramento and Seattle are all on the west coast of the US. New Jersey is on the east coast. The package made a cross-country trip that it didn't need to.
I wonder if it would be cheaper for NASA to outsource some of their experiments to the Russian agency?
Really, I can think of a lot of cool experiments for the serious scientist. Things like insect eggs in space, effect of zero-G on seeds, that kind of thing
Except NASA is forbidden, by law, from doing this.
I'd heard this several times, but
this [spacedaily.com] is the only current reference to the law I can find (see the fourth and fifth paragraphs). Here is an older article [space.com] about the restriction before it was passed.
I reckon my postie will be rightly pissed if he has to ride his bike all the way from the space station Post Office to my appartment. But he does need the exercise so if anyone wants to send mail to me this way.. feel free.
$60K for it to come back down?!! What are they trying to do, get it delivered in one piece or something?! Like that ever happens with regular post.
To get it back down I can't see why they wouldn't just throw it out the window. Sure, it may do a few thousand laps of the earth first (just like regular post), and it my burn up on reentry (your own fault for inadequate packaging), but think of the amount of Mohammed Saeed al-Sahaf merchandise you could buy with the savings.
ehh. the bbc article seems a bit confusing about this.
the per kilogram costs are cited from some russian sources as what it costs THEM to move that mail first up, then down, and to process it. one kilo fits quite many of those 20k$-30k$ letters.
NASA's a government bureaucracy - PROFIT is the last of their goals... Remember this proposal wasn't from free-enterprise America, but from (no longer Soviet-) Russia...
This has got an expensive "just because i can" and useless coolness factor to it like, renting a suite in a nice hotel, getting a buggy when playing golf or using a Palm handheld
Instead of dicking around with post-offices in space, why doesn't Russia offer to put a wireless webserver into space and sell access?
Just think -- budding entrepreneurs could buy space on the server and upload copies of popular movies or music which people could then download for a small annual subscription using a regular satellite disk and PC card.
How would the RIAA/MPAA kill that bird I wonder?
Does the DMCA reach that far above the earth's surface?:-)
We spent many thousands (millions?) inventing a pen that would write in the low-gravity of space. Finally, we came up with a pen that had a nitrogen-charged inkwell to push the ink out.
Why would anyone want that, when you can actually talk [nasa.gov] to the peeps up there, which is free if you have the necessary license/equipment (which is easy to get and cheap)...
I've been trying for years to send mail to the post office that Apollo 15 left on
the moon [alanbeangallery.com]. Although this was a notable achievement for the newly reorganized USPS, it doesn't seem to have a ZIP code...
Diving into stupid buisness models a-la internet bubble.
Obligatory slasdotisms 1. find stupid people to give us $20,000 to put a piece of paper in space and bring it back 2. ???? 3. PROFIT!!!
What a horrible waste of resources. What does one get out of knowing that a piece of paper went into space? Retarded.
Also, as far as the article goes, why are return costs so high for pulling back to earth a kilo of material? You've already spent the $10,000-20,000 per kilo to GET something into space, much less fuel is
So lets say you deicde to drop $20,000 on a letter to space. How do you know it gets there? Do they send the letter back after, is it a round trip thing?
And if it is, how do you know it hasn't just been half way around the world, not to our orbit and back? You can't. Do the contents smell different once they've been to space? Do they get heavier or lighter? NO!
If the $20,000 is a one-way thing, they might as well throw it out before it gets on the spaceship... claiming it contained dangerous materials, or
Of course in the story it was decided that the weight penalty of actually taking the mail to the moon to be franked was excessive so a little fraud was perpetrated instead...
And can someone explain to me why you would want to do this for $20,000? Are the Russians really that hard up for money that they would try this scheme? If I was someone who was incredibly rich (and didn't care how my money was spent) I would send a box with a camera in it so I could see if it actually got to space.
imagine if we did to them what we did to Ralsky.......jesus, slashdotting the ISS with junk mail can't be a good thing. And the best part is hopefully the junkmailers would pick up the cost because they figure maybe SOMEONE finally wants to buy their product.
I once heard about a guy who built his house in the Alaskan wilderness by mailing himself cinder blocks. They were far cheaper to mail than to ship to wherever it was he was building.
NASA could learn from this and mail components to the ISS, instead of shipping them up in their own spacecraft.
-aiabx
uhhhhh (Score:5, Insightful)
What would the point be except for rich people to claim that they spent 20k on a stamp basically. I know of some crappy fundraisers, but this one sucks.
I'd rather them just ask for donations really. It'd be more honerable I think.
Re:uhhhhh (Score:1)
Re:uhhhhh (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:uhhhhh (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:uhhhhh (Score:1)
So $5,300 x 2 = $20k?
If only NASA ran an airline--then I could buy my one-way ticket home for 1/4 of the price instead of purchasing the (currently cheaper) round trip ticket.
It's all a matter of mass (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:uhhhhh (Score:2)
The ashes stay in space - the letter hopefully comes back. The expense is in making the fligh a round trip.
-josh
Re:uhhhhh (Score:2)
Re:uhhhhh (Score:1)
whereas to put mail up you would need to possibly have astronauts in with the mail which would mean life-support
then again in They may just be stamping the letter in russia and "saying" that it was from space
only $20,000!? (Score:5, Funny)
no, wait (Score:2, Interesting)
# Delivery of one kilo of cargo to the ISS: $10-20,000
# Return of one kilo from the ISS to Earth: $60,000
# Cost of one hour's work by the team aboard the ISS: $18-19,000
"Cost of one hour's work by the team aboard the ISS: $18-19,000"????
does this mean i have to pay for the post and the time to read it?? or does it mean i can pay an extra 20g's to have them do what ever i want? id donate to a fund to have lance take an hour space walk w/ no space suit!
oh crap, i probably shouldnt post
Re:no, wait (Score:3, Funny)
id donate to a fund to have lance take an hour space walk w/ no space suit!
Or how about have'em sent there a kilo at a time...
No (Score:5, Funny)
But, if you want to save $2K and achieve the same result...
1. Put Lance in an envelope with the sender's address as "Space Station, Earh Orbit"
2. Mail him to your own address
3. Refuse to accept him and send him back to the post office
4. The PO will send the mail back to the original sender, i.e. the Space Station
That would require postage though. (Score:1)
I'm not sure if that works anymore, but I remember reading about how someone did this and they succeeded in mailing something, without postage, to one of their friends in the same city.
working up to pigs later (Score:2, Interesting)
Spammmm innnnn Spaaaaaaaace!
I think someone should be kind and mail them a Victoria's Secret catalog, or similar amusement. I know I would appreciate it, were I in orbit.
Somehow, I think this post is reason enough not to read slashdot at 4:30am...
Re:working up to pigs later (Score:3, Funny)
Jason
ProfQuotes [profquotes.com]
Re:working up to pigs later (Score:2, Funny)
Perfect murder (Score:2)
Additionally, you always get a push in the opposite direction of where you noodle is pointing to (impulse laws). As Stanislaw Lem noted in "The Fiasco" (*): The perfect murder in space would be to place a naked person in the middle of a room, hovering. He mentioned that you have to be sure that that person has an empty digesting system and an empty bladder. The person would simply starve to death without any opportunity to reach the walls. He seem t
No sound in space (Score:1, Redundant)
And if we're lucky, permenantly!
load size? (Score:4, Interesting)
It looks like a good method for space-based experiments, at least until a cost-effective private alternative is created.
Re: load size? (Score:2, Funny)
> One question is whether the $20,000 for the stamp is merely an additional cost, or if it includes the cost of transporting a kilogram or so of cargo.
Sounds like someone's thinking about becoming the system's first astrodealer. You reckon they smoke a lot of pot on the ISS?
Re:load size? (Score:2)
just the symbolic act of your LETTER having travelled to iss and back.
and that's it. just a way to get financed, and a way to give something symbolic back to the people donating, making the donating much 'easier' for cheapskate-minded people with lot of money.
Re:load size? (Score:5, Insightful)
those numbers were there for so that you could try to calculate the PROFIT they get from the letter, and if it was worth it for the russians to sell such service. it costs THEM $10-20,000 per kilo, $60,000 to return that kilo, and $18-19,000 per hours work of astro/cosmonauts.
Re:load size? (Score:1)
For that cost, I think I'd go with DMT instead of THC.
Re:load size? (Score:1)
$10-20,000 for delivery to ISS.
$60,000 for return to Earth.
$18,000 min. for 1 hrs. work.
So at least $88,000 for a key of DMT.
Still, less than it costs now. Great sales pitch though.
Now all I have to do is figure how to produce one key of DMT for less than $200k.
In Soviet Russia... (Score:5, Funny)
Re: In Soviet Russia... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:In Soviet Russia... (Score:2)
Russian mail delivery... (Score:2)
Re:Russian mail delivery... (Score:1, Funny)
Re:Russian mail delivery... (Score:1, Insightful)
No - that's US mail, with Total Information Awareness [darpa.mil]
Great excuse... (Score:5, Funny)
I shudder to think of the kind of bills you'd need to have a $20-$30K stamp be a cost effective stalling method. I doubt they'd launch your letter before their check clears, at least.
Re:Great excuse... (Score:1)
Re:Great excuse... (Score:1, Funny)
It is, and we hate you back, but with WMDs. Perhaps you're on our liberation list?
I wonder... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:I wonder... (Score:1)
rubber stamped space mail (Score:3, Funny)
Just a big scam... (Score:1)
Assuming they did send it to space, would you get refunded if the letter was on a shuttle that had a Columbia-like disaster?
Hmmm... (Score:1)
No Next Day Service (Score:1, Troll)
Bleh, rip off more like it, hehe.
Whats the point? (Score:3, Insightful)
Rus
Re:Whats the point? (Score:3, Funny)
$20,000 for spam-free mail! (Score:2)
Re:$20,000 for spam-free mail! (Score:1)
Now, there's the just "little" problem of collecting that mail.... or even receiving some...
Routing. (Score:2)
Re:Routing. (Score:2)
Re:Routing. (Score:2)
Re:Routing. (Score:1)
NASA... (Score:3, Informative)
Really, I can think of a lot of cool experiments for the serious scientist. Things like insect eggs in space, effect of zero-G on seeds, that kind of thing
Re:NASA... (Score:1)
Except NASA is forbidden, by law, from doing this.
I'd heard this several times, but this [spacedaily.com] is the only current reference to the law I can find (see the fourth and fifth paragraphs). Here is an older article [space.com] about the restriction before it was passed.
I'd like to recieve the mail... (Score:5, Funny)
Well (Score:3, Funny)
Cost, $20K is only one way. (Score:2, Informative)
Re:Cost, $20K is only one way. (Score:1)
Re:Cost, $20K is only one way. (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Cost, $20K is only one way. (Score:1)
Re:Cost, $20K is only one way. (Score:4, Informative)
the per kilogram costs are cited from some russian sources as what it costs THEM to move that mail first up, then down, and to process it. one kilo fits quite many of those 20k$-30k$ letters.
Just wait... (Score:5, Funny)
Would they ever be able to decontaminate the place, or would they have to scrap the entire station?
Re:Just wait... (Score:2, Funny)
At $20 000 a pop... (Score:2)
Re:At $20 000 a pop... (Score:2)
Stamp image question (Score:1)
Just curious about the consumer group they are trying to target.
NASA's new business model (Score:5, Funny)
2) Tell people to send letters for 20K
3) Scan letters
4) email letters
5) Print letters on ISS
6) PROFIT
Re:NASA's new business model (Score:1)
NASA, a business model? (Score:2)
p-mail, e-mail, now s-mail... (Score:1)
What's next, SG1-mail?
It shouldn't be too hard to mail Lance (Score:5, Funny)
Coolness factors.... (Score:2, Interesting)
A bit too much? (Score:2, Interesting)
An idea... (Score:2)
...you could send an engagement ring up there before use... just think of all the corny lines you could get away with...
Er, no, actually, I can't think of any either. Ah well.
A request... (Score:2, Funny)
Sounds like a great idea. I have one request though...
For the return trip, he takes the shuttle.
Bad taste, I know, sorry. ;)
A touch of space (Score:3, Funny)
Not just the wedding rings.
But you could send your favorite SIFI junk then send it up and back again and sell it on as truly out of this world.
Same kind of thing for new age healing power of space type junk
Very special edition Franklin Mint includes 0.001% of real space exposed material
That's just a few moments of thinking
Here's an idea... (Score:2)
Just think -- budding entrepreneurs could buy space on the server and upload copies of popular movies or music which people could then download for a small annual subscription using a regular satellite disk and PC card.
How would the RIAA/MPAA kill that bird I wonder?
Does the DMCA reach that far above the earth's surface?
Email cost $0.00 (Score:2)
Maybe Russians are more simple minded than us?
Re:Email cost $0.00 (Score:2)
The russians used a pencil.
an alternative way to deal with spammers! (Score:1)
If they don't, punish them by firing them into space.
Without a space suit.
ah finally (Score:1)
Why would anyone want that? (Score:3, Informative)
well... (Score:2)
Maybe somebody could "accidently" send him into deep space?
Earth orbit? So what? (Score:2, Interesting)
Space mail (Score:1)
If I can raise enough funds... (Score:1, Redundant)
Lost Mail....it happens (Score:1)
Then i'm 20 thou out?
-Grump
More like..... (Score:2)
Obligatory slasdotisms
1. find stupid people to give us $20,000 to put a piece of paper in space and bring it back
2. ????
3. PROFIT!!!
What a horrible waste of resources. What does one get out of knowing that a piece of paper went into space? Retarded.
Also, as far as the article goes, why are return costs so high for pulling back to earth a kilo of material? You've already spent the $10,000-20,000 per kilo to GET something into space, much less fuel is
It would Make GBWR... (Score:2)
as the most expensive letter ever Returned to Sender.
(thank you, thank you very much)
How can you tell? (Score:1, Insightful)
And if it is, how do you know it hasn't just been half way around the world, not to our orbit and back? You can't. Do the contents smell different once they've been to space? Do they get heavier or lighter? NO!
If the $20,000 is a one-way thing, they might as well throw it out before it gets on the spaceship... claiming it contained dangerous materials, or
one word (Score:2)
Anthrax
Heinlein thought this up 40-50 years ago ... (Score:2)
Of course in the story it was decided that the weight penalty of actually taking the mail to the moon to be franked was excessive so a little fraud was perpetrated instead
Send a letter to space... (Score:2)
now all knowledge of gravity aside.... (Score:1)
the reason someone would pay this (Score:2)
How much do you think the first stamp to be sent to a post office in space would go for? A hell of a lot more then 20K!
Only a Matter of Time Before The USPS Charges This (Score:2)
Your government monopoly at work...
Where is Lysander Spooner when we need him?
Imagine what a subscription would cost (Score:2)
A good way to reduce construction costs (Score:2)
NASA could learn from this and mail components to the ISS, instead of shipping them up in their own spacecraft.
-aiabx
Excellent (Score:1)
this is a bad idea..... (Score:1)
white powder, and anthrax.
Who would use the service? ( Was: Re:FP!!!) (Score:2, Insightful)
And like most first posts, yours is a total waste of a message.
My question is who, other than topical philatelists, would be interested in sending snail mail to orbit for $20K.
I do know of some philatelists who are crazy enough to do that, but then, philatelists are crazy, anyway.
Wind under They Wings
Amber
Re:Who would use the service? ( Was: Re:FP!!!) (Score:2)
Re:blech (Score:1)