Stars Form Near Milky Way's Supermassive Black Hole 32
New submitter Aspiring Astronomer writes: Scientists report that stars have likely formed near the supermassive black hole in the heart of our galaxy. How does this happen, if a black hole exerts so much gravitational force that not even light can escape? Astronomers believe the black hole may actually facilitate the formation of these stars. According to study author Farhad Yusef-Zadeh, the gases and dusts constantly flowing toward black holes compress and heat up, creating enough disturbance to cause the materials to collapse and then form a star. Yusef-Zadeh speculates that in addition to stars forming near black holes, planets may form there, too. The disk around a protostar (a mass of gas and materials that form early in star formation) breaks off into clumps of matter, and when paired with the extreme force of a black hole, may cause the formation whole planets.
clarification (Score:5, Informative)
"How does this happen, if a black hole exerts so much gravitational force that not even light can escape?"
The stars don't form inside the black hole, so I don't see how that is related. Instead they are at a distance of several light years, where some of the gas that falls towards the center stops (angular momentum; similar gravitational attraction of black hole and galaxy stars). The gas can collapse and form stars. These are called "nuclear star clusters".
Re: (Score:3)
That being said, I still wonder about effects of gravitational time dilation and the odds of very rare things happening (such as life developing). Probably only the stuff of science fiction, but the first thing to pop into my head, nonetheless.
Re: (Score:3)
I'm not sure if you thought about it, but "square of the distance between the objects" only applies to single masses, "point sources" in ordinary Newtonian mathematics. When you look at a spiral shaped galaxy full of stars, and you're measuring the _net_ effects of gravitation and the relative potential energy differences among them and the net forces acting as one enters the actual accretion disk of matter surrounding its core, it can be confusing. Whether it is a black hole isn't the issue, the effect I r
Re:clarification (Score:5, Funny)
Similar mysteries to be solved:
- How can there be dolphins near an island, since an island is land, and dolphins cannot survive on land?
- How can there be people near a mountain, since the weight of the mountain is enough to crush people?
- How can there be birds near a nitrogen tank, since nitrogen doesn't sustain life?
Re: (Score:2)
Now THAT was funny!
Re: (Score:1)
Re: (Score:2, Insightful)
"How does this happen, if a black hole exerts so much gravitational force that not even light can escape?"
God, I'm sick of that particular bit of hyperbole. Escape velocity is sqrt(2GM/r), so once an object is (M) massive enough, the escape velocity is greater than the speed of light. That doesn't make black holes magical, it doesn't make them marauding, all-devouring nomadic cosmic muggers, and it doesn't allow them to pull things in that are too far away to be pulled in; any more than the earth can pull
Re: (Score:2)
Obviously you have never watched a Hollywood film...
When? (Score:1)
Scientists report that stars have likely formed near the supermassive black hole in the heart of the our galaxy
TFS doesn't give any time indication. Since it seems to be some breaking news, was that yesterday? Thursday?
Thought Experiment (Score:5, Insightful)
Scientists used to believe that no life would exist at the bottom of the sea around hydrothermal vents do to the kack of light, high heat, and toxic chemicals. Then they visited the hydrothermal vents in subs and found them teeming with all sorts of crazy life, violating their expectations in the most extreme way possible. Perhaps the same holds true for planets near supermassive black holes. And that that's where most of the life is in the galaxy. And that Earth is a bunch of intra-galactic hicks living out in the sticks. Which is why we haven't found any evidence of extra-terrestrial life yet.
Re:Thought Experiment (Score:5, Informative)
Re: (Score:2)
it's obvious you have no attitude whatsoever for it
It's obvious you are the one with the attitude.
Re: (Score:3)
Comment.
If you are new around here and plan on coming back I suggest you spend quite awhile looking over stories and their comments from years past. This place has it's own... You'll figure it out.
Re:Thought Experiment (Score:4, Interesting)
Also when people think of super massive black holes they think of violent, scary, life suckling masses. Compared to the smaller ones they are tamer as they have such a great surface area that stars near there can stay for away from the event horizon for billions of years due to subtripical force and the fact gas gets pulled from great distances
Re: (Score:1)
subtripical force?
I guess you mean stars can survive for a long time due to the balance between the centripetal force exerted by the black hole (pulling the star towards the center of its orbit) and the centrifugal force exerted by the circular motion of the start around the black hole (apparently pushing the star away from the black hole but actually just inertia trying to make the star follow a straight path).
Re:Thought Experiment (Score:4, Interesting)
Scientists used to believe that no life would exist at the bottom of the sea around hydrothermal vents do to the kack of light, high heat, and toxic chemicals. Then they visited the hydrothermal vents in subs and found them teeming with all sorts of crazy life, violating their expectations in the most extreme way possible. Perhaps the same holds true for planets near supermassive black holes. And that that's where most of the life is in the galaxy. And that Earth is a bunch of intra-galactic hicks living out in the sticks. Which is why we haven't found any evidence of extra-terrestrial life yet.
The problem with this is a simple matter of time. The stars thus created don't have the luxury of billions of years, or tens of billions of years in the case of lower-mass stars than our sun, to evolve complex life. It would also be a problem that, if they were to survive long enough to evolve a space-faring civilization, they would need to find a way to carry the escape velocity from the black hole in addition to all of the other energy necessary just to get away from their home planet.
Re: (Score:2)
imagine a life and civilization evolving, looking out at their immediate galactic neighborhood, becoming aware that this weird night sky shape that their ancient ancestors worshiped is a supermassive black hole... and then growing an awareness of what that means for their future
how depressing
Re: (Score:2)
They would sing songs about life, love and the obliteration of all life in the universe ;)
Re: (Score:2)
"life as we know" is only life on earth. that's a sample size of one. not a useful guide for the kinds of life that might exist or that we should expect is out there
Real Experiment (Score:3)
imagine a life and civilization evolving, looking out at their immediate galactic neighborhood, becoming aware that this weird night sky shape that their ancient ancestors worshiped is a supermassive black hole... and then growing an awareness of what that means for their future
Imagine a life and civilization evolving, looking out at their immediate galactic neighbourhood, becoming aware that this glowing ball of light that their ancient ancestors worshiped is a star... and then growing an awareness of what that means for their future in a couple of billion years when it has heated up enough to terminate all life on their planet.
We don't need to do a thought experiment because we are in almost exactly the same predicament. It might be a couple of billion years rather than a fe
Misleading summary... again (Score:2)
This is NOT a report. This is not based on observation, either direct or indirect. This is simply a claim based on a theoretical paper providing a theoretical explanation of how this could happen (if the author's theory is correct).
Re: Misleading summary... again (Score:2)
Interstellar comes to mind (Score:2)
"Perling" effect (Score:1)