LHCb Experiment Observes New Matter-Antimatter Difference

An anonymous reader writes "Matter and antimatter are thought to have existed in equal amounts at the beginning of the Universe, but today the Universe appears to be composed essentially of matter. By studying subtle differences in the behavior of particles and antiparticles, experiments at the LHC are seeking to cast light on this dominance of matter over antimatter. Now the LHCb experiment has observed a preference for matter over antimatter known as CP-violation in the decay of neutral B0s particles. The results are based on the analysis of data collected by the experiment in 2011."

A: Becuase it breaks the flow of a message

[DNS-and-BIND]

Q: Why is starting a comment in the Subject: line incredibly irritating?

I know /. editors love CERN

[Lawrence_Bird]

but the headline is a bit grandiose - there is nothing new about CP violation. CP violation has been known for a very long time and there are at least three other examples of it prior to LHCb report. Also, as CERN notes, others were not able to accumulate sufficient statistics to make the observational claim. Perhaps "CERN's LHCb confirms CP violation in another particle" my be both a more accurate way of describing it and also less "omg, ponies!"

Re:I know /. editors love CERN

[hajus]

For the electroweeak force yes, but not in the QCD Lagrangian. B+ meson CP violation is the new part.

Re:equal amounts at the beginning of the Universe

[Anonymous Coward]

If that were the case, then reactions that produce anti-matter would be detectable before they occur.

Good question!

[Roger W Moore]

How do we know this?

We know this by looking for gamma rays produced by matter/anti-matter annihilations. The solar wind does not annihilate with out atmosphere so we know the sun is made of matter. This same wind does not annihilate with the interstellar medium in the galaxy so that is made of matter. No other star has visible annihilation lines with this medium either so we can be sure the entire galaxy is made of matter. Further out out galaxy does not create annihilations with the medium in the local super cluster of galaxiesand neither does any other galaxy so we know that the local super cluster is all made of matter.

To go further afield is harder since at this point the distances rule out detecting gamma rays from the incredibly sparse intergalactic medium (at least this was true several years ago - perhaps astronomers can do better now?). So instead what you can do is look at galactic collisions. No colliding pair of galaxies emits gamma radiation consistent with annihilation events so either the universe is really perverse and somehow no pair of colliding galaxies is ever a matter/antimatter pair OR there are no anti-matter galaxies out there to collide with. So while it is impossible to rule out that there might be one or two anti-matter galaxies hiding in some distant corner of the universe there are clearly far, far more matter galaxies than anti-matter ones.

First Law of Thermodynamics

[Roger W Moore]

Actually there is [wikipedia.org]. Of course it is only interested in thermal energy but nevertheless it is there. One of the most beautiful bits of mathematics, Nöther's Theorem [wikipedia.org], shows that for any symmetry there must be a conservation law (or vice versa). For energy the cause of the conservation law is that the laws of physics are all symmetric under translation in time i.e. the laws of physics today are the same as they were yesterday. So while the reason for energy conservation has nothing to do with thermodynamics it is still stated as its first law.