Neutrino Oscillations Confirmed 122
mfg writes "The Sudbury Neutrino Observatory has found evidence that neutrinos can change type between the Sun
and Earth. See the
BBC news story for more details."
1 + 1 = 3, for large values of 1.
Why are the neutrinos interesting? (Score:0, Interesting)
Re:Why are the neutrinos interesting? (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:Why are the neutrinos interesting? (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Why are the neutrinos interesting? (Score:4, Interesting)
It's called science. You make a hypothesis, and you try and prove it by experimentation. Simple really.
With the sort of attitude shown here, Einstein would never have bothered looking at discrepancies in Newton's laws of motion and gravitation, and there would be no theories of relativity. Heisenberg/Bohr/Planck (and all the others) would never have looked at discrepancies in black body radiation etc and quantum theory would never have been thought of. And then I wouldn't be writing this, because semiconductors would never have been discovered.
Just because there's no immediate application in a particular field doesn't make it important. Stop thinking of that great big $ sign.
Re:Point? (Score:4, Interesting)
There is a good deal of tension between advocates of basic versus applied research, and there needs to be a better dialog. Currently it is a bunch of people throwing around assumptions about the merits of both types of research, but no one seems to really engage the other. (IMHO).
As an aside, there was a link [bbc.co.uk] from the article about the Japanese detector. Seems that one of the tubes blew which set of a cascade that destroyed most of the remaining tubes. I can't imagine the boom that one made...
Re:Why this matters.... (Score:5, Interesting)
At normal neutrino flux levels, it'd take several times the lifespan of the universe for neutrinos to deposit even the tiniest amount of energy into a slice of bread. Consider the fact that many billions have passed through your body in the time you've been reading this comment. It's unlikely a single one of them would actually collide with a particle in your body.
A neutrino toaster would probably need the total neutrino output of the sun to toast a slice of bread in a reasonable time period - and if you've got that, why not just stick your bread on a real long fork and toast it over the sun's corona
Re:Why this matters.... (Score:2, Interesting)
Lets ignore the technical impossibilities for a second here.
Actually we already have a good application already. we have proved that the sun is working as we expect. There was two possibilities for the missing neutrino's.
1. The theories were wrong
2. The sun was very ill.
Personally I feel a lot richer for knowing 2 is not the case.
Can we use this technology as a way to monitor the sun?
Re:Neutrino MASS?? (Score:2, Interesting)
But it is important. . . isn't it? If I recall my physics correctly, neutrinos with mass = closed universe.
It's funny when you think about it, that probably the smallest particle in the universe will decide its fate. . . but it's true. Pretty amazing stuff, physics.