World's First Fuel-Cell Motorcycle 481
Alex writes "Rubber Magazine reports that the British company Intelligent Energy has unveiled today the first purpose-built, fuel-cell motorbike. The bike has a 6kW (8 hp) electric motor, top speed of 50 mph (80kph), a range of 100 miles (160km). The engine is completely silent, which might not go well with many motorcycle lovers. In addition it could also possibly pose an interesting safety issue, since a pedestrian or motorist would not hear it coming."
Cool (Score:5, Insightful)
We bicyclists have the same problem, but if one obeys the rules of the road, there should be no problem. The problem bicyclists (and many motorcyclists) have is with people in their automobiles who fail to properly look out and are too busy talking on the damned cell phone while driving their gas sucking SUVs. (Disclaimer: I own a Toyota 4runner, but bicycle back and forth to work every day, and run many of my errands on the bicycle) My recent experience with a near miss can be read here [utah.edu].
The engine is completely silent, which might not go well with many motorcycle lovers.
I have to admit that when I did ride motorcycles, there was a certain magic about either the banshee wail of a sport bike as you wound it up while screaming up a canyon road or even the relaxed "POTATO POTATO POTATO" of the Harleys. However that said, this is going to be the future of transportation and I would most certainly embrace fuel cell technology that reduces the worlds outrageous consumption of oil. Plus, this ENV bike is a pretty sweet looking ride.
Re:Cool (Score:5, Funny)
It's not a problem really. Just tape a playing card to it so it flaps against the spokes. Worked for me when I was a kid. Between that and the banana seat, I was too cool for school.
Re:Cool (Score:2)
Uhh...no you weren't. You were just cool enough.
Re:Cool (Score:2)
Why do spinners scream to me: "playing card in the spokes!"
Re:Cool (Score:2)
They always remind me of pinwheels. Like the kind 4 year old girls (used to?) play with. The first time I saw spinning rims, I had to check for the rainbow sticker on the rear windshield.
The holdup on the playing card (Score:2)
If anyone is ever going to develop a perpetual motion device, my bet is on an electric vehicle designer.
Ah, but the card bends back - does it not? (Score:2)
Think of the card as a simple spring, storing energy when bent and releasing it to straighten out once more.
Re:Ah, but the card bends back - does it not? (Score:2)
Ninjas are sweet! They flip ou and just not care (Score:5, Funny)
Yes, but the bike will be a huge smash hit with NINJAS!
'My name is robert, and Ninjas are soooo sweet.'
Its the weight that concerns me. (Score:5, Insightful)
Even on my bike 500lbs I get tossed around alot on windy days... I wouldn't want to be on this bike if an 18 wheeler passed me on the highway.
Re:Its the weight that concerns me. (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:Its the weight that concerns me. (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Its the weight that concerns me. (Score:3, Insightful)
The situation is hardly better if on a motorcycle.
Re:Cool (Score:2)
Re:Cool (Score:2)
It's also worth realising that part of the problem is that cyclists are fundamentally harder to see and even while looking for you drivers still have to keep en eye on what's happening in front of them etc.
I don't drive a bike but my car is fairly low and I know there's a good chance that someone in a 4WD (SUV) stands a good chance of not seeing me if I'm just behind them or even directly
Re:Cool (Score:2)
So they pull out and hilarity ensues (as long as you have decent gear on).
Re:Cool (Score:2)
consumption of oil only gets reduced too if you're not making the hydrogen from oil
the 'no sound' issue is pretty stupid to worry about(making noise is easy).
Re:Cool (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Cool (Score:2)
Re:Cool (Score:3, Insightful)
Personally, I'd like to see both the 2AM fuckwit yuppie straight-pipe-equipped Harley riders and the 7AM loud stereo with the windows d
Re:Cool (Score:2)
Would it make a difference whether the Harley driver were going in to work at 2AM? If not, how does it matter what your friend was doing at the time?
I'll grant that it's possible to over-the-top wrt loud pipes -- but the biggest risk to a competant motorcyclist is cagers who don't
Re:Cool (Score:5, Interesting)
Unfortunately, that's just a risk we riders face when we get on the road. We deal with that risk by assuming no one can see us (other than traffic cops!), and anyone who thinks that loud pipes will alleviate that risk is either rationalizing or not terribly bright.
I don't see that many riders with loud pipes dressing completely in yellow, which they would do if making others aware of their presence was really the foremost consideration. There is no statistical proof that loud motorcycles increase rider safety, and any anecdotal evidence is easily overcome by anecdotal evidence that people are annoyed by motorcycle noise. It's not like we need to give someone in an automobile more excuse for their road rage. You might think I'm being paranoid, but I firmly believe that a healthy dose of paranoia makes for a healthier rider.
Re:Cool (Score:3, Interesting)
Maybe this is the solution. Have a loud stereo system on the bike that's looping an MP3 of a Harley. Then they'll hear you coming, and you won't get ticketed.
Re:Cool (Score:2)
Loud pipes DO save lives.
A motorcycle is supposed to make noise. However, I'd be down with all the cars going to this tech, leaving the gasoline for the bikes....
Now all it needs... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Now all it needs... (Score:2)
Re:Now all it needs... (Score:2)
Re:Now all it needs... (Score:2)
If you think "H-bomb" automatically means "tactical", all I can say is you just aren't creative enough! Or perhaps "destructive" is the word I'm looking for.
Meh (Score:2)
Re:Meh (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Meh (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Meh (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:Meh (Score:2)
says who ? (Score:3, Informative)
my statio wagon is a 1200 kg volkswagen parati with a 1800cc engine produces 90 hp and at 80 km/h it does... 12 km/l.
an engine 14 times bigger only needs twice the fuel to move a car 7 times the weight of the motorcicle.
moto myths (Score:5, Informative)
Myths:
Adding noise - the low tech way (Score:2)
However, a lot of small commuter bikes are pretty quiet - quiet enough that they serve no pedestrian warning purpose - so I don't really see an issue here.
For those unclear on the point... (Score:2)
girls love bad boys.
bad boys ride Harleys.
Re:moto myths (Score:5, Interesting)
Having a loud bike will protect you because motorists will be able to hear you.
I hate to bum the high of all of the Harley riders out there but I've met quite a few guys who have been in serious motorcycle accidents (i.e., they ended up having a leg cut off) and quite a few of them had big, noisy cruiser style bikes. The Hurt report (yes, that's what it is called) didn't find any correlation between how much noise a motorcycle makes and its likelihood of being involved in an accident with another vehicle.
Jamie - former motorcylist, current amputee
Re:moto myths (Score:2)
Re:moto myths (Score:4, Informative)
Re:moto myths (Score:5, Interesting)
Yeah! You speak the truth my friend. If I had mod points, you'd get them. I'm partial to older bikes, especially 80's standard Japanese bikes, and older BMWs. The bearded tatooed Harley thugs/wannabethugs and the tshirt/shorts/flipflops crotch-rocket-cool-dudes all look down on these, but I love them. Power aplenty, nice handling, and comfortable riding positions. I once took an early 80s Nighthawk 650 on a 1500 mile trip. It was a blast.
As an aside, I learned how to adjust my valves this weekend (1978 BMW R80/7), and after a spline lube this coming weekend, I'll know most of the basic maintenance for this machine. I'm a wannabe motorcycle geek right now - hope to be halfway competent in a couple years - but looking forward to some extended motorcycle camping this summer.
NOT Flamebait (Score:2)
Re:moto myths (Score:5, Insightful)
motorcycle around as some kind of penis extender.
That's because you notice the loud bikes, dangerous riders, etc.
Just like if someone says "the only thing on the road are these huge SUVs". That's because they are big and you are looking for them- a Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, etc is generic enough that you don't notice it. That doesn't mean they aren't there.
A Goldwing isn't a cruiser, and you probably haven't seen many people pulling wheelies on them. Others: nearly every bike by BMW, many dualsport and adventure bikes by other makers, the SV650 and clones. These bikes aren't cruisers or sportbikes- they are standards. Sure, there are stupid people on bikes, but there are stupid people on cars, too.
Many of us follow the MSF or Team Oregon philosophy, reducing our risk as much as possible. Don't judge an entire population based on a miniscule subset.
-ted, motorcycling geek who doesn't need to compensate
Re:moto myths (Score:2)
i notice plenty of penis extender riceboys too, but since there are so many cars on the road, the ratio of idiots is much lower.
the only thing on the road isnt huge SUVs, and i dont know anyone who says that. most of the cars are little 4d sedans and such. it's not a matter of being noticeable, its a matter of simple statistics.
if one were to go to a busy intersection or street and count idiot d
Re:moto myths (Score:2)
-ted
motorcycle lovers (Score:5, Insightful)
Somehow, I think that the top speed of 50 mph might not be that popular either.
nope, might as well ride a scooter (Score:2)
you miss the point (Score:2, Insightful)
50mph in London or for that matter any British city ? good luck with that between 7am-10pm
Re:you miss the point (Score:2)
In Town Driving (Score:2)
Plus you dont have to deal with 18 wheelers blowing you off the hiway since its SOOO light...
Need to stick one of these powerplants in a current electric car..
There's also the issue of the puny 8HP motor... (Score:2)
That also implies rotten accelleration. (Score:2)
That also implies that the accelleration is pretty puny, too. One of the points of motorcycles is that they can accellerate drastically to pull ahead out of trouble. (That helps to make up for not being able to brake heavily without risking going down.)
It's also one of the points of electric-motor drive: A motor can put out a LOT of torque.
Right now it's a glorified lazy-man's bicycle, suitable for in-town commuting only.
Bump up t
Solution to silent cycle (Score:2, Redundant)
Quiet? Not a problem (Score:2)
Haven't these guys ever heard of the cardboard in the spokes trick?
silence in cars too (Score:5, Interesting)
Damn silent pedestrians (Score:2, Funny)
You'll hear me coming - I'm the one yelling "HEY ASS****!" at the car trying to hit me.
Re:silence in cars too (Score:2)
[homage to the 80s, or was it the 70s. Damn I'm old]
(Lack of) Noise Problem (Score:2, Interesting)
In addition it could also possibly pose an interesting safety issue, since a pedestrian or motorist would not hear it coming.
Easy. Put baseball cards between the spokes. Problem solved.
Fark had this yesterday (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Fark had this yesterday (Score:2)
Motorcycle as reviewed by an Interior Designer (Score:3, Funny)
Also I wonder how many people go to rubbermagazine.com and are a little disappointed when they get there.
I need one (Score:3, Funny)
lightweight (Score:3, Insightful)
The ENV is really a big, quiet H2 scooter. The difference is really just in the marketing, but that creates the mindset in the rider. Ride it like a Harley, get squashed like a bug. Ride it like a Razor, and rule the road.
Better off-road handling (Score:2)
For dirtbike riding, rather than a help, weight is a huge impediment. It makes the bike less responsive to rider input, harder landing when you jump, and more dangerous when you fall off (which you do a lot m
huh? (Score:5, Interesting)
The wind is a problem if you happen to sit fairly high up on a motorbike with a big side profile (aka most 'high performance' road bikes). Even if said bike weighed a lot you'd probably still be moved around quite a bit as you go fast. The wind is a lot less of an issue on choppers since you're sitting way lower and they have way smaller side profiles.
= has trouble hugging curves in mountain roads
huh? What does weight have to do with anything when talking about cornering? You don't see MotoGP riders strapping anvils to their bikes to corner better, do you?
= needs more acceleration to stay at speed despite drag.
this doesn't make any sense: AFAIK the drag is proportional to the bike's frontal area, not to its weight.
= while a heavier bike will absorb more momentum.
if you collide with a car and you're on a motorbike you're going to be thrown off it whether or not the motorbike weighs 200lb or 500lb: most/all cars outweigh you by an order of magnitude anyways, and let's not even talk about SUVs.
= these collisions are really terrible mismatches for a bike, especially one which can't jet out of the way at higher speeds
most of the bike-car collisions I've seen/heard about couldn't be avoided by being able to accelerate or go faster: if that was the case there would be no accidents involving high performance road bikes, right?
Personally I think this bike is perfect for European city commuting (since it's near silent and non-polluting odds are you'll be able to drive it in the city centres that are currently off-limits to mopeds and motorbikes) but won't really do much here in North America, although you might see the odd one around (like I've seen a S.M.A.R.T. car the other day, the likes of which you see way more often in Europe).
The 80kph speed limit is about perfect as well, as traffic usually moves around at 50-70kph in town: my old moped was capable of hitting 60-65kph (on a good day, with some tailwind) and having an extra 20kph would be way more than enough for those times where traffic is moving faster than usual.
refills? (Score:3, Funny)
Re:refills? (Score:2)
Re:refills? (Score:2)
Excellent timing (Score:2)
Drive By? (Score:5, Funny)
Core = power solution (Score:5, Insightful)
But the battery is reusable, and can be used else where. Camping, Emergency Generators, vehicals, kids toys, etc.
And as for the quiteness of them, new problems are only new challenges. Most people cant hear whats outside their car now, with the radio on, speaker phone, and kids crying in the back.
Funny how quiet is a drawback, when I'm thinking quiet traffic is worth it. You dont jay-walk for a reason, now you dont hear the car hitting you, maybe its darwinism in realtime.
good for commuting... (Score:2)
Congestion would be reduced because it's easier to maneuver a motorcycle than a car.
Pollution would be drastically reduced (once adoption rate is high enough).
Parking would be WAY easier, since a cycle takes like 1/3 or less the space of a car.
Silent Harley Gang!! (Score:2)
mu ha ha ha
no noise? not a hazard (Score:3, Insightful)
Why is it any different with a motorcycle? Loud pipes annoy the rider and nearby pedestrians. The visibility issue with motorcycles is more a function of size than volume.
-ted, motorcycling geek
SF ENVy? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:SF ENVy? (Score:2, Informative)
Safety solution... (Score:2)
How about having a man with a red flag and a horn run in front of it to warn others? It is a tried solution [wikipedia.org].
As a motorcycle owner (Score:5, Informative)
Now my 250cc Rebel (my firts bike) puts out 15 HP. So, an 8 HP bike might be a bit weeny for highway cruising, but this sounds like a great city bike.
In terms of noise again, bicycles and even Segways make no (or very little) noise. Its not the pedestrian who has an issue. Its the driver.
If its licensed like a standard Gas powered bike, then the driver knows the rules on riding and should not be endangering anyone.
I applaud this and all the other cool alternative fuel bikes. My little bike gets 70 mpg, and my biggest get 35 mpg. Not bad compared to most cars people actually drive, but they still add to the pollutiuon level none the less.
Re:As a motorcycle owner (Score:2)
A better comparison would be a somewhat efficient, somewhat lightweight motorcycle- after all, your Corolla is a somewhat efficient, somewhat lightweight car. And then make a straight comparison- are you talking about city driving? Urban commuting? Long distance interstate driving?
-ted
Re:As a motorcycle owner (Score:2)
I don't think he was saying that at all.
I don't know about the Corolla, but I do know about the VW diesels. My two got 50+ MPG under ideal conditions, and 40 MPG running on number 1 fuel in the winter, in the hills.
So, a practical economy car, in average conditions, can beat the fuel economy of a big motercycle.
Anybody else scared of... (Score:2, Funny)
Eep.
(From the article: "a bike
(Granted, not fusion, but still. Hinden-nads... Eep!)
New Market Segment (Score:2)
Watch me Not Care (TM) (Score:5, Insightful)
Pardon my French, but fuck 'em (read till the end for why, I have a little explaining to do first).
In my state (Massachusetts) a bunch of do-gooders are working on legislation to ban "aftermarket" exhaust systems on cars (and cars only) which are "louder" than the OEM systems. This was originally intended to stop all the idiots with Hondas from putting practically-open mufflers on their 4-bangers. Which IS really annoying.
However, for people like me who own an older German car for which the exhaust system OEM costs about a bazillion dollars, pretty soon I won't be able to install a significantly cheaper exhaust system, simply because it is slightly louder than the original, and the original was dead quiet...or because I'd have to have it "tested" or the manufacturer would have to have it "certified".
Meanwhile, some guy who thinks he's really Bad Ass (TM) gets to run COMPLETE STRAIGHT PIPES off his damn Harley that are so loud they make your chest pound. Or some college student on a crotch rocket puts mufflers on his bike that are so loud he sounds like an screaming F1 car. Nevermind none of these idiots have catalytic converters, and the damn things are little better than lawnmowers; most of them are still using carbs (yes, I know some "sport bikes" are now EFI, whatever, that's not the point). They're emissions -nightmares-, and while I have to have my car strapped to a dyno every 2 years, he barely has to have his blinkers checked.
So, until that law applies to them (it does NOT) AND cops start holding motorcycles to EXISTING noise limits, don't you dare go telling me what I can/can't do with my car's exhaust...and certainly don't whine to me about how a fuel-cell bike makes no noise.
Thank you. Yes, I am done.
Re:Watch me Not Care (TM) (Score:2, Troll)
I got a warning ticket for loud pipes last year and guess what I still ain't putting the damn baffles in them.
Then the cop that gave me the ticket said he doesn't like loud pipes because we
Re:Watch me Not Care (TM) (Score:3, Informative)
14. Conspicuity of the motorcycle is a critical factor in the multiple vehicle accidents, and accident involvement is significantly reduced by the use of motorcycle headlamps (on in daylight) and the wearing of high visibility yellow, orange or bright red jackets.
18. Conspicuity of the motorcycle is most critical for the frontal surfaces of the motorcycle and rider.
I have a hunching feeling th
Re:Watch me Not Care (TM) (Score:3, Informative)
You're way off. My ride's a GSX1200, stock pipes. The bike can pull 0-60 in 2.9 seconds, but its quiet enough to slip up behind someone at a crosswalk without their noticing from a meter aw
I have to wonder.... (Score:2)
It could be ironic that high oil prices might actually hurt fuel cell development since the companies that rely on cheap oil are the ones that are also pushing the development of fuel cells.
Another Fool Cell (Score:3, Informative)
Re:Another Fool Cell (Score:3, Informative)
Aritfical Noise? (Score:3, Funny)
Am I the only one (Score:5, Funny)
Sweet silence! (Score:2)
Too friggen bad.....
Why does everyone have to make so much friggin noise?
Punks blast up and down my street with 200,000 watt bongomaster systems and no mufflers.
The sound pressure levels of these things are so high that they cause physical pain in my head.
I have a right to peace and quiet. These people invade my home with their offensive "music" and excessive noise.
It's the "my dick is bigger than your dick" syndrome
Chick magnet (Score:3, Funny)
Just the thing for picking up vegan babes at the PETA rally.
left wanting to know more (Score:2)
Price? Availability? (Score:2)
Silence is golden. (Score:3, Interesting)
I think they should perhaps have speakers embedded into their helmets to blast their own ears away.
-grin-
I think some form of speaker system can be installed which will simulate some form of engine noise (Star Wars vehicles come to mind...) to help with the safety issue. Besides, the noise of some motorcycles prevent the rider from hearing others around them.
I too drive a 3.0 litre Porsche 911 SC, and am painfully aware how bad it is for the environment (and my fuel budget). Fortunately event though my exhaust needs to be replaced (I almost sound as bad as a free-flow modified VW Beetle!) the car is totally silent within. (Pretty cool really)
I'll miss the roar I think, but then again I'm all for viable (quasi-)electric vehicles.
For those of us... (Score:3, Funny)
Dan East
Exactly, they just annoy people (Score:2)
For the record, I do have a motorcycle... Its not extremely loud (stock pipe) but my neighbour, well, 4 houses away can wake the dead when he starts up in the morning.
Re:Vroom. (Score:2)
Electric motorbikes have one less design problem than the cars. Fumes from batteries don't matter since they can't build up in an enclosed space with people in it. With fuel cells it's even simpler, since you aren't sitting on a big pile of batteries.
Re:Noise (Score:2)
If its electric you might not ever have to shift gears - the thing will literally go like a locamotive. Also a lighter bike can be set up to have very good acceleration - so you'll be ahead for a little while at least.
I saw one electric bike put together six years ago by some engineering students that had very good acceleration - but they traded off the top speed to 50km/hr and range to 100km to get that. With the batteries s